Tuesday, July 21, 2009
The Truth is Discrediting Thailand
The Foreign Ministry on Tuesday denied a Washington Post news report that there was a secret US prison for international terrorists in Thailand.
Asean Affairs Department director Vitavas Srivihok said the Department of Information will look into the source of the report and release the facts to the public.
"The report may be aimed at discrediting Thailand, as the chair of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean)," Mr Vitavas said.
Foreign Affairs Minister Kasit Piromya's secretary Chavanond Intarakomalyasut also insisted there was no secret prison in Thailand. The Thai government had never let the United States build a torture facility in the country.
"Mr Kasit said even though the report was groundless, this issue must be clear as it is discrediting the country," Mr Chavanond said.
According to the Washington Post report, the secret CIA facility was used to interrogate and torture terrorist suspect Abu Zubaida in 2002 after he was captured in Pakistan.
This is the world the Thai media lives in. No regard for truth and all regard for fantasy.
Once again, notice that the Thai media refuses to do any independent investigation of its own, it just accepts whatever the government tells them to think, regardless of how stupid it may sound.
By the way, there is more to this story than one report. Many terrorists were either arrested in Thailand or brought to Thailand from somewhere else and tortured.
The International Red Cross did a report on torture in Thailand also. Did the IRC just write the report back in 2007 to discredit Thailand today?
When Hambali was captured and tortured in Thailand was that to discredit Kasit and Abhisit and their precious ASEAN summit?
When Khalid Sheik Mohammed was brought to Thailand was that just another conspiracy to get Kasit, probably the dumbest foreign minister in the history of foreign relations, and to discredit Thailand?
Abhisit and Suthep deny the US Secret Prison Story
Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva insisted on Tuesday morning that there was no secret prison for torturing terrorists in Thailand as reported by the Washington Post newspaper.
Mr Abhisit said there was no cooperation between the Thai government and the US in setting up a secret prison as alleged.
“It’s an old story and it is totally groundless as this government has never resorted to the use of violent means,” Mr Abhisit said. The report would not affect the summit between Asean and its dialog partners being held in Phuket.
Mr Abhisit said he will meet US Secretary of State Hilary Clinton at Government House about 5pm today.
Deputy Prime Minister Suthep Thaugsuban took the same tone. He stressed that the report of a secret prison in Thailand by the US newspaper was groundless.
Mr Suthep said it was suspicious that the report surfaced during the Asean meeting in Phuket.
Why does the Thai media allow the government to get away with this? Why does the Thai media insist talking about the present as if it were the past?
Abhisit and Suthep weren't in power back then. The Washington Post story wasn't about the present government.
Why are these games of semantics allowed?
Why doesn't the Thai media ask the players who were in power back then, like their beloved General Surayud?
Suthep is a joke, as if the Washington Post went out of its way to publish the story to disrupt the ASEAN summit. I'd be willing to wager my entire worth for the rest of my life that the Washington Post doesn't give two shits about the ASEAN summit or Thailand's reputation.
Monday, July 20, 2009
More US Media Exposure on Torture in Thailand (that the Thai media refuses to touch)
In April 2002, as the terrorism suspect known as Abu Zubaida lay in a Bangkok hospital bed, top U.S. counterterrorism officials gathered at CIA headquarters in Langley, Va., for a series of meetings on an urgent problem: how to get him to talk.
Put him in a cell filled with cadavers, was one suggestion, according to a former U.S. official with knowledge of the brainstorming sessions. Surround him with naked women, was another. Jolt him with electric shocks to the teeth, was a third.
One man's certitude lanced through the debate, according to a participant in one of the meetings. James E. Mitchell, a retired clinical psychologist for the Air Force, had studied al-Qaeda resistance techniques.
"The thing that will make him talk," the participant recalled Mitchell saying, "is fear."
Now, as the Senate intelligence committee examines the CIA's interrogation program, investigators are focusing in part on Mitchell and John "Bruce" Jessen, former CIA contractors who helped design and oversee Abu Zubaida's interrogation. These men have been portrayed as eager proponents of coercion, but the former U.S. official, whose account was corroborated in part by Justice Department documents, said they also rejected orders from Langley to prolong the most severe pressure on the detainee. The former official's account, alongside the recollections of those familiar with events at the CIA's secret prison in Thailand, yields a more nuanced understanding of their role than has previously been available.
Interviews with nearly two dozen current and former U.S. officials also provide new evidence that the imposition of harsh techniques provoked dissension among the officials charged with questioning Abu Zubaida, from the time of his capture through the period when the most grueling torments were applied.
In August 2002, as the first anniversary of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks approached, officials at CIA headquarters became increasingly concerned that they were not learning enough from their detainee in Thailand. When the interrogators concluded that Abu Zubaida had no more to tell, Langley scolded them: "You've lost your spine." If Mitchell and his team eased up and then al-Qaeda attacked the United States again, agency managers warned, "it would be on the team's back," recalled the former U.S. official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss classified information.
---
A Breakthrough in Bangkok
In early April 2002, some officials at the CIA's Counterterrorist Center were not convinced that the man in U.S. custody was indeed Zayn al-Abidin Muhammed Hussein, Abu Zubaida's given name. The Saudi-born Palestinian, then 29, had been sought by the FBI on suspicion that he played a role in a foiled 1999 plan to attack Los Angeles International Airport and tourist destinations in Jordan.
The detainee had been captured in Pakistan in late March 2002 after a firefight that left him wounded in the thigh, groin and stomach. After being treated in Pakistan, he was flown to Thailand for interrogation.
The CIA dispatched FBI agents Ali Soufan and Steve Gaudin for an initial look. The two men arrived a few hours before the wounded man was transferred to a hastily assembled CIA interrogation facility near one of Bangkok's airports.
Details of their experience and that of the CIA officials who followed them to Thailand with Mitchell were gleaned from public testimony, official documents and interviews with current and former intelligence and law-enforcement officials with access to confidential files. Through the FBI, Gaudin declined to comment for this article, and Soufan referred reporters to his congressional testimony and other public statements.
---
On the agents' first night in Thailand, Abu Zubaida went into septic shock because of his wounds and was rushed to a local hospital. Gaudin and Soufan dabbed his lips with ice, told him to ask God for strength and cleaned him up after he soiled himself, according to official documents and interviews.
At his bedside, Gaudin asked Soufan to show Abu Zubaida a photograph of Abdullah Ahmed Abdullah, an Egyptian suspect in the bombings of two U.S. embassies in Africa in 1998. The two agents had photos of terrorism suspects on a handheld computer, and Gaudin accidentally displayed the wrong photo.
Abu Zubaida said: "This is Mukhtar. This is the mastermind of 9/11."
The agents did not know that Mukhtar, a name that had surfaced in some raw intelligence and an Osama bin Laden video, was a nickname for Khalid Sheik Mohammed. Nor did they know that Mohammed was an al-Qaeda member.
Abu Zubaida had given the agents the first positive link to the man who would later be charged as the chief planner of the Sept. 11 attacks.
---
With the FBI's breakthrough, the CIA recognized that the captured man was indeed Abu Zubaida and began assembling a team to send to Thailand. Agency officials had no firm notion of what a post-Sept. 11 interrogation of a terrorism suspect should look like.---
Mitchell boarded a CIA plane for Bangkok with R. Scott Shumate, a CIA psychologist; two agency officers who worked undercover; and a small team of analysts and support staff, including security personnel to control Abu Zubaida.
Among those on the plane was an agency expert on interrogation and debriefing, an officer who was part of a training program intended to help the agency detect double agents and assess recruits for foreign espionage. The trainers taught strategies for extracting sensitive information but prohibited coercive tactics.
When Mitchell and the CIA team arrived in Thailand, Abu Zubaida was still in the hospital. The two FBI agents, Soufan and Gaudin, met the CIA officers at a nearby hotel for a debriefing.
Although senior CIA officials in Bangkok were nominally in charge, they deferred to Mitchell, according to several sources familiar with events at the prison
---
In the initial stages, Abu Zubaida was stripped of his clothes while CIA officers took turns at low-intensity questioning. Later, Mitchell added sleep deprivation and a constant bombardment of loud music, including tracks by the Red Hot Chili Peppers. After each escalation, he would dispatch an interrogator into Abu Zubaida's cell to issue a single demand: "Tell me what I want to know."
---
In Bangkok, word circulated among those at the secret site that the tactics had been approved "downtown" -- agency jargon for the White House.
---
Soufan testified to Congress in May that Abu Zubaida went silent once Mitchell took charge. Within days of the CIA team's arrival, the cables between Bangkok and Langley became devoid of new revelations. Agency officials decided to let the FBI back into the interrogations, but on the condition that forced nudity and sleep deprivation be allowed to continue.
The CIA team lowered the temperature in Abu Zubaida's cell until the detainee turned blue. The FBI turned it back up, setting off a clash over tactics.
---At the secret prison, dissent over Mitchell's methods peaked. First Shumate left, followed by Soufan. At the site, Shumate had expressed concerns about sleep deprivation, and back in Langley he complained again about Mitchell's tactics, according to the former U.S. official and another source familiar with events in Thailand.
Then one of the CIA debriefers left. In early June, Gaudin flew to Washington for a meeting on what was happening in Thailand, and the FBI did not allow him to return.
Jessen, newly retired from the military, arrived in Thailand that month. Mitchell and his partner continued to ratchet up the pressure on Abu Zubaida, although Bush administration lawyers had not yet authorized the CIA's harshest interrogation measures. That came verbally in late July and then in writing on Aug. 1, paving the way to new torments.
Interrogators wrapped a towel around Abu Zubaida's neck and slammed him into a plywood wall mounted in his cell. He was slapped in the face. He was placed in a coffin-like wooden box in which he was forced to crouch, with no light and a restricted air supply, he later told delegates from the Red Cross.
Finally, he was waterboarded.
Abu Zubaida told the Red Cross that a black cloth was placed over his face and that interrogators used a plastic bottle to pour water on the fabric, creating the sensation that he was drowning.
The former U.S. official said that waterboarding forced Abu Zubaida to reveal information that led to the Sept. 11, 2002, capture of Ramzi Binalshibh, the key liaison between the Hamburg cell led by Sept. 11 hijacker Mohammed Atta and al-Qaeda's leadership in Afghanistan.
But others contend that Binalshibh's arrest was the result of several pieces of intelligence, including the successful interrogation by the FBI of a suspect held at Bagram air base in Afghanistan who had been in contact via satellite phone with Binalshibh, as well as information gleaned from an interview Binalshibh gave to the television network al-Jazeera.
Abu Zubaida was waterboarded 83 times over four or five days, and Mitchell and Jessen concluded that the prisoner was broken, the former U.S. official said. "They became convinced that he was cooperating. There was unanimity within the team."
---
The two men threatened to quit if the waterboarding continued and insisted that officials from Langley come to Thailand to watch the procedure, the former official said.
After a CIA delegation arrived, Abu Zubaida was strapped down one more time. As water poured over his cloth-covered mouth, he gasped for breath. "They all watched, and then they all agreed to stop," the former official said.
A 2005 Justice Department memo released this year confirmed the visit. "These officials," the memo said, "reported that enhanced techniques were no longer needed."
So, basically, General Anupong lied to the Thai public about the secret prison and got away with it. I knew he was lying, but the Thai media let him get away with his lie.
I have done a lot of research on this topic. I've just been neglectful and lazy about putting it all together.
General Surayud was the Army Commander back then. Do you think the Thai media is going to ask him any questions about this? Or the Thai intelligence agencies?
By the way, this is only the tip of the iceberg. Other Al Qaeda terrorists were captured in Thailand and/or detained and probably tortured.
Hambali being the most famous one. Kavi broke the story for The Nation. If you go back to The Nation's coverage of the events after Hambali was captured, Kavi knew Hambali was being detained and tortured, because he was reporting on the interrogations.
Khalid Sheik Mohamed was brought to Thailand and tortured.
Mohammed Farik Bin Amin aka Zubair and Mohammed Bashir Bin Lap aka Lillie(NY Times declassified paper) were captured and tortured in Thailand. Other biographies.
Here is a Time magazine article from 2003 that explains their exploits.
These were not good guys.
Regardless, that is no reason for the Thai military and for Kavi to cover the story up.
General Anupong quote in the Bangkok Post:
Army chief Anupong Paojinda insists the United States has no secret jail in Thailand for captured terror suspects.
"I insist there's no such place in the army. I guarantee a million per cent with my position as guarantee," Gen Anupong said.
The army chief said there were no such secret places in Udon Thani.
" You can go everywhere, every district, every tambon in the province [to check]," he said.
Asked why the information the US has a secret jail in Thailand had been confirmed in the US, Gen Anupong declined to comment.
Do you think anybody in the Thai media will demand General Anupong's resignation for lying?
Nope.
2Bangkok has a really good link list of all the Thailand related secret prison articles.
Saturday, July 18, 2009
Suthep Resigns MP seat, retains real power, gives Thaksin like excuses
Deputy Prime Minister Suthep Thaugsuban has resigned as an MP over the Election Commission's conclusion that he had violated the constitution by holding shares in prohibited businesses.
Mr Suthep yesterday tendered his resignation as a Democrat MP for Surat Thani's Constituency 1.
However, Mr Suthep said he will not quit the ministerial post.
Mr Suthep was one of 28 Democrat MPs investigated for the alleged offence.
The EC has recommended the disqualification of 13, including Mr Suthep, for breaching the shareholding ban.
The charter prohibits MPs from holding stakes in media and telecom firms and from holding shares in firms granted state concessions. The recommendation will be forwarded to the Constitution Court.
Mr Suthep said he had decided to quit as an MP because he did not want to get involved in an imminent drawn-out court battle.
He said he needed time to focus on other pressing matters.
"I need to concentrate on my job as deputy prime minister in charge of national security. I don't want to waste time preparing for a court fight."
Mr Suthep said he sold all his questionable shares before becoming a member of the cabinet last year.
He said the charter was not violated because all his share transactions were carried out through the stock market.
He claims to have sold them off before the shareholding restrictions came into force and had no intention of abusing his power or interfere or dominate companies with state concessions.
"Since I began holding those shares in 1995, I never attended any of the shareholders' meetings," Mr Suthep said.
It never ceases to amaze me how all the people who have so much contempt for Thaksin and his weasley ways act exactly like Thaksin in every way.
These Democrats always have pathetic excuses for flouting the same laws they created to get rid of their enemies.
Friday, July 17, 2009
Thanong's Astrologer: The Insanity Continues
I heard that the people in green uniforms are making some unusual movements in preparation for something big. Many people are also feeling worried about the solar eclipse that will take place on July 22. The solar eclipse is seen by some as a bad omen for countries directly affected by it. Most people also would like to know whether there will be any serious political incidents between now and July 22, and beyond. The country is still in turmoil.
So I decided to consult my favourite astrologer.
"What can we expect from this eclipse?" I asked.
"It's gonna be pretty bad," she said. "It will adversely affect the astrological sign of Cancer. We don't know whether it will hurt Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva or Thaksin Shinawatra, the former prime minister. Both are Cancer. Either could get hit."
"The military is making unusual movements. I smell a coup. Does it have anything to do with the eclipse?" I asked.
"If the military were to stage a coup, they should do it now. The alignment of the stars is on their side. The eclipse on July 22 would be ideal because it is when there is an eclipse over the country. If they wait longer, the timing will slip away," she said.
The astrologer added: "But in the period before or after the eclipse, the water element would create problems. I don't understand why Abhisit has decided to host the Asean summit in Phuket, surrounded by water. His advisers should have consulted the stars first."
---
Let's wait for the solar eclipse to see whether the bad omens will come true. Sometimes we have to give in to the stars in the sky.
It is horrifying that The Nation is actually transforming itself into Not the Nation---and still taking itself seriously. The farce has become the reality. Just when you think the absurdity of The Nation's opinion pages can't get any worse, the editors go and top themselves.
I would love to be a fly on the wall when the foreign sub-editors are going over this stuff. It must be a laugh a minute.
Monday, July 13, 2009
To pass Abhisit's ethics test for Foreign Minister, Take over an airport and break international law
Kasit Piromya meets the ethics standards set down for cabinet members and should stay in the cabinet, insists Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva.
The embattled foreign minister had no credibility problems, Mr Abhisit said while denying claims the government had interfered in the legal case now before him.
Mr Kasit is facing charges for his part in last year's blockade of Suvarnabhumi airport. Critics say he should resign immediately.
Speaking on his weekly television programme, the prime minister yesterday said he would not dismiss Mr Kasit over his involvement in the People's Alliance for Democracy's blockade of the airport.
"At this stage, where a summons has been issued, there is no need to dismiss him from the post," Mr Abhisit said.
"Initial checks found that the minister has no credibility problems."
Mr Kasit is among 36 PAD leaders and key supporters facing terrorism and other criminal charges for the Nov 25 to Dec 2 occupation of Suvarnabhumi and Don Mueang airports.
The blockade was part of a campaign to force the government, led by the now-defunct People Power Party, to give up power.
Abhisit is tone deaf. If The Nation, your biggest propagandist, calls on Kasit to resign, you better start re-thinking this strategy.
Sunday, July 12, 2009
Kooky Kasit Piromya Lashes Out at His Enemies
Foreign Minister Kasit Piromya on Sunday has challenged a group of army officials who wanted Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva to dismiss him for a televised debate. Mr Kasit, who has been charged with committing an act of terrorism by police, said he had enough of being criticised without substantial evidence by different sides.
The evidence is well, self-evident. He announced to the whole world in the front of foreign journalists that he took pride in the airport takeovers.
"I do not know who those army officials are, but I must ask why didn't they protect their country when former prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra was ruining it," he said.
I guess Kasit forgot about the coup. By the way, Kasit had no problems working for Thaksin or taking his money.
The embattled minister said those who criticised him should reveal themselves.
"There are many evil politicians walking inside and outside the parliament, and why don't people pressure them to resign," he said.
None of them took over an airport, violating international law, and bragged about it.
Mr Kasit said he would like to ask Deputy Prime Minister Suthep Thaugsuban who actually wanted to harm Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva and People's Alliance for Democracy leader Sondhi Limthongkul.
Kasit is a loose cannon. In any civilized country, he would have been sacked. Interesting that the foreign minister is accusing the deputy prime minister for security for wanting to harm Abhisit.
Clearly, Abhisit doesn't have his government in order. So far, he has proven to be an incompetent manager.