Google
 
Showing posts with label Atiya Watch. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Atiya Watch. Show all posts

Saturday, May 23, 2009

Deconstructing Atiya Achakulwisut: Evil Farang Pick on Poor Thailand, Leave Burma Alone

Bangkok Post


re: Daw Aung San Suu Kyi

This is a democratically elected leader of a severely oppressed country whose people have long suffered under the heavy boots of the military junta. A leader who was not only robbed of her election victory but of her basic human rights for decades, who is now facing a real threat of being tried unfairly and put away in jail for five more years. Where is the outcry from the foreign media? Where are the articles and high-minded opinion pieces condemning the undemocratic elements? Where are the lectures and derision?


Atiya is a delusional hypocrite. When has there ever been an outcry from Thailand? Thailand is Burma's biggest economic partner and the Thai military and politicians have been propping up the Burmese junta for decades with moral and business support. Further, the western media has been a hundred times harder on Burma than on Thailand. Burma is almost at the level of Axis of Evil state; Thailand is only at fucked up and can't get its shit together state.


Has the bad press been reserved for struggling democracies like Thailand? Like, if you try real hard to hold your stuff together and be compliant with Western values, you get slapped when you come up short. But if you are a fully-fledged autocracy that shuts the country off from unwanted relations (and keeps the wanted relations plus profit to yourself) who also could not care less about what the world may think, then you can be left alone. No foreign press would nag that the Burmese prime minister was not elected, that its roadmap to democracy is a coup-produced sham, or that Snr Gen Than Shwe has not been seen smiling or anything.


It seems Atiya has been reading too much of The Nation and has destroyed her brain cells. Where does she come up with this outrageous crap? The western media has never been a friend of the Burmese junta. In typical Thai media fashion, Atiya can't come up with one article, one paper to support her argument.


The Economist, for example, has been harsh on Thailand to the point that its own integrity can be called into question. In its April issue, for example, the magazine took aim at Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva's mandate to govern. "He rode to office, unelected, thanks to the yellow shirts," the magazine stated.


There is no doubt, at least to me, that the Democrats came to power on the coat tails of the PAD's terrorism that brought the country to a standstill.


What is the Thai media's obsession with The Economist? They really have a problem with anybody having a contrary opinion to their own.


The statement would have proven the magazine's theory about Thai democracy being usurped by undemocratic elements - had it not been factually wrong. One has one's own doubts why such an esteemed publication would opt for dispensing false information for the sake of being critical of a country.


Atiya really has fallen as a journalist to sink to such fallacious argumentation. She is almost as bad as Thanong and Sopon. Like The Nation, she equates The Economist not agreeing with her opinion as an attack upon Thailand.


The same magazine has this to say when it comes to Burma: "According to this view the top generals are wicked, but not everyone inside the system is. And given the state of Myanmar's economy, the choice may be between working with the government and not working with anyone."


What does this quote have to do with anything? What is the implication here? That Atiya has poor English comprehension skills?


It's probably this kind of attitude (and profit that can be made from natural resources that Burma has to offer to those who please them) which allows the Burmese dictators to feel free to oppress. They know that if they don't care about the world, then the world will have no choice but to work with and through them. They also know that if they would just come up with some absurd charges against their political opponents, the world would not put any pressure on them except to wring their hands and sing the same old global chorus of being "so concerned".


Again, Thailand has been the worst supplicater and enabler of the Burmese junta and its authoritarianism. Thailand and the Thai generals are the biggest exploiters of Burmese natural resources. What has ASEAN done except to only invoke its policy of non-intervention? The West, on the other hand, has strict economic sanctions against Burma.


Do you think Atiya would support an international peace keeping force on Thai soil that would invade Burma and depose the junta? Of course not, because the Thai media is in the pocket of the Thai military generals and the Thai military generals are the Burmese junta's biggest business partners.


The truth is that democratically elected Aung San Suu Kyi should never have been placed under house arrest and no country should be "working" with the military junta that took power by force, save to make them relinquish their grip.


Maybe Atiya's vitriol should be saved for the Thai government that has legitimized the Burmese junta time and time again.


It is quite puzzling how the world press is ready to heap scorn and pressure on a half-baked democracy like Thailand's and refrain from applying the same kind of heat to a fully-fledged dictatorship like Burma's. Maybe they think it is an exercise in futility because the Burmese generals won't care. But that would then be an act of hypocrisy.


Why does Atiya have to lie? She is either intentionally misinformed or a liar. Truthfully, the international media doesn't care that much about Thailand. In terms of human rights and international attention, Burma is a bigger cause. This is indisputable.


And the Burmese people can't afford any more hypocrisy from a world that preaches democracy and human rights protection.


Maybe Thailand can't afford a hypocritical Thai media that supports the crimes of the Thai military while wringing its hands over the Burmese military.


Bangkok Pundit did a much better fisking of Atiya's column here.


The irony of Atiya's column is that the entire Thai media would go absolutely apoplectic if the evil foreign media harshly criticized Thailand one percent of the time it criticizes Burma. The notion that Thailand is picked on more than Burma is the lamest argument I have read since Sopon's last column.



Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Deconstructing Atiya Achakulwisut: A Spurned Woman's Analysis of Politics

Commentary: Dissolve the House

By Atiya Achakulwisut

Bangkok Post


The PM has had many chances to prove his mettle, to show that he could rise above the limits and demands of his banal "self'' to serve other people or fulfil a noble cause. He has failed consistently. He has failed to listen, as evident during the special joint session he himself convened for the specific purpose of giving him advice. He has failed to look beyond his ego to see the reality of what other people are feeling _ what conflicts are on their minds. He has failed to hold his tongue even though he knew that in raising his voice to try to protect his perceived stature, he ended up crowding out ideas and thoughts which he should have heard.


The more Prime Minister Samak speaks, the deeper the crisis seems to plunge. In parliament, he spoke of the need for him to stay put so that he can be seen as preserving the democratic system against mob rule. It sounded noble, but I couldn't help thinking whether it was too pompous for the premier to equate himself with the whole regime. Does he truly believe that he is so indispensable that were he to step down the whole democratic system would go down with him?


I shall call this the spurned woman argument. Wah, you don't listen to me. Wah, you only care about your ego. Wah, you don't read my mind. Wah, if you don't do as I say, I will throw a temper tantrum. Wah, if you don''t cave into my demands, you are a bad and evil man.


Japanese Prime Minister Yasuo Fukuda stepped down because his popularity rating was considered low _ not that anyone had come out into the streets to demand his resignation. How is that? Quite a few names have been put up as candidates for the top job, but, at last check, democracy in Japan has not crumbled.


Oh Samak, Why can't you be like a Japanese man? Japanese man better than you. He loves me, he coddles me, he caves in to my hysteria, he sweet talks me when I am upset.


The democratic system is not one man, not even about one government. It's a process. It's a contest. And it's a negotiation, constantly evolving to find an equilibrium. At this point, the process has worked itself into a tight corner. Even if Mr Samak were to tender his resignation today, the crisis will not be resolved. With clashes and casualties, the confrontation has sharpened to the point that nothing short of resetting the process, setting up new terms for negotiation, will help.


Oh, Samak, not everything is about you. You have to look at the greater good, which is me and my feelings.


The issue and challenge right now is to bring the situation back from the brink. It's understandable if Mr Samak does not want to be seen as kowtowing to the PAD's demand by resigning. But it's obvious he cannot stay in his position when he has no power left to rule. He can't crush the protesters. He can't wish them away. So, the only thing he can do that is still in his power and within the democratic principle is to close down the House and start it all over again at the ballot box.


Oh, Samak, your manhood doesn't matter, your integrity doesn't matter. The only thing that matters is that you castrate yourself for me. Why can't you see how evil you are? I only know what is good for the family. You drink with your buddies and you screw other women. You ignore me, you don't care about me. Why don't you do yourself and the world a favor and off yourself?

It's true there is no guarantee the PAD will move out of Government House once the House is dissolved. Still, the act would radically reduce the degree of confrontation. With the Samak government gone, how would the PAD justify its aggression?


There is no guarantee either that the new government will not run into another wave of opposition. But I suppose we will have to deal with that when it comes. And we may have to start getting used to the idea of having an election every year or so, if need be. Consider it a process of democratic re-education.


It's true too that a House dissolution would not solve the crisis. However, we might as well accept by now that our current political crisis is so complex and involves several layers and levels of disagreement that there is no one-shot remedy that can possibly cure it.


Our hope _ if we still have any left at present _ should be in stopping the highly partisan and emotionally-charged crowds from butchering one another. With the government gone, everyone will have the much-needed chance to exhale and probably take another deep breath before we deal with whatever problem is to come.


It is within Mr Samak's power to take that first step, to nullify the currently too tight conditions that allow people to do nothing but clash with one another; then set up new terms of engagement and hope that new negotiations will take place. It's true that Mr Samak might lose any chance of coming back as premier. But he will gain a new status in brinkmanship.


Oh Samak, I know that once I get rid of you there is no guarantee I won't meet a man just like you and repeat the same patterns in my life.

I have been secretly flirting with Abhisit. He is handsomer, smarter and more effete. He seems like the type who will cave when I break his balls. When I smile and shake my ass at him, he reacts, like a cute puppy dog. You are just pig faced beast who scowls and swears and does what he wants.

That doesn't matter though What can I do? You are in my life now. You are the only one I hate now. You are the one who is the source of all evil in my world.

When the next man comes along, hopefully Abhisit, don't worry, I will complain about him just as much as I complain about you if he doesn't represent the perfect fantasy I have in my head of him.

Here is the knife, my love, please cut off your penis and feed it to the ducks yourself. I know that will only give me a temporary satisfaction, but at least I will feel good and self- righteous for the moment. Quickly though, Abhisit is waiting.




Friday, May 11, 2007

Deconstructing Atiya Achakulwisut: Courageous Critical Column Attacking General Sonthi


No time for a general to play games


cache

Atiya Achakulwisut

Bangkok Post


Chairman of the Council for National Security Gen Sonthi Boonyaratkalin reassures no one with his excuse that he was misled into accepting a petition calling for the removal of PM Surayud Chulanont. At best, the lame apology heralds to the public that our chief of security is clueless not only about the goings-on inside the country -- he has no idea what the network of Isan people led by People's Alliance for Democracy (PAD) member Chaiwat Sinsuwong was up to -- but also about the efficiency of his own staff. If true, the excuse that he was misinformed about the agenda and thus canceled other things to receive the group because he thought they would brief him about the political undercurrent in the Northeast, reflects badly on the capability of the general himself. If the CNS chairman can be duped that easily, what hope do we have? At worst, the scenario conjures up deja vu of an ominous kind. The meeting followed the exact same pattern as the one between Gen Sonthi and his namesake, Manager Media chief and a PAD leader, Sondhi Limthongkul, at the height of the protests to oust then prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra in February last year. Even the claim by Chaiwat and Sondhi after meeting the general is almost the same: that Gen Sonthi listened to them attentively and would consider their request, to get rid of the PM, then and now. Gen Sonthi's reaction to news about both meetings was also the same --to deny that he actually intended to receive, lend weight or give endorsement to the PM busters. Truth be told, seven months after the meeting between Gen Sonthi and Sondhi --widely seen as an invitation by the PAD for the military to take over-- the former led the Sept 19 coup that successfully toppled former PM Thaksin.


Absolutely amazing, calls General Sonthi a two faced liar, a conspirator, and a bumbling fool all in one paragraph. I have to admit that this is courageous writing.


Chaiwat's connection with the PAD --which has been calling for PM Surayud's resignation as well --and by extension Sondhi, is obvious. Gen Sonthi's deja vu action leaves a lot of room for doubt, which is just what the country can't afford at this critical moment when so many things will be coming together.


Some of these doubts would include whether Gen Sonthi would resort to staging another coup to oust his former army boss? Who would be the replacement premier? Would he or she stick to the same deadline for the general election? Or are we looking at a ''postpone until further notice'' sign regarding the country's attempt to return to democracy?


No confidence in Sonthi at all. Is the writing on the wall with this column?


None of these questions bodes well for a country struggling to regain its footing. Abroad, Thailand is trying very hard to explain to the world, and the United States in particular, about the need for compulsory licensing of two Aids drugs and one heart medication, to avoid further trade sanctions. Domestically, we are grappling with a downturn in the economy whose painful effects are beginning to be felt by a number of people, and the ongoing violence in the deep South which threatens to get out of hand with each passing day.


In other words, these idiot generals don't know what they are doing in terms of international politics, the economy, and domestic problems.


Under the circumstances, Gen Sonthi has no room for lame excuses. He must start showing smartness in his moves. Tough issues await, including the verdict over the possible dissolution of the Democrat and Thai Rak Thai parties, which is due at the end of this month and has the potential to stir strong emotions in millions of supporters of each party. Such a strenuous situation demands a strong and capable hand. The public would be hard pressed to place their trust in a security chief who is so easily misled by his own people or by a group of people with vested interests; or in someone who seems unhappy with the running of the country but can't seem to do anything to make it better.


Absolutely amazing. Atiya has got some big cahones.


Gen Sonthi has recently begun riding in the bullet-proof Mercedes once used by ousted PM Thaksin. Gen Surayud is also reported to have a brand new four-wheel vehicle equipped with a receiver-transmitter capable of detecting and jamming telephone signals used in detonating bombs. But in the deep South, men from their old affiliation, the Special Forces, were bombed while riding in a military pick-up with no back-up vehicle; each of them was shot dead execution-style after that. This is no time for the generals to play games. Both Gen Sonthi and PM Surayud must get their act together or risk ruining everything.


I have been following the news for a long time. I don't think I have read an op-ed like this from one of the two English dailies, ever.

Damn, I want to kiss Atiya. Where has she been all this time? She has a lot of guts.

Those idiots at The Nation need to take writing and courage lessons from the new love of my life.