Google
 
Showing posts with label Thai propaganda. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thai propaganda. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 16, 2007

The Nation: The Government Can Tax for Another Government TV Station, But Not For Drugs to Save Lives

TITV operations to be financed by 'sin' taxes

The Nation

Cabinet backs move for tobacco, alcohol taxes to pay for independent station

Up to 1.5 per cent of "sin" taxes would be utilised to sustain TITV after it received Cabinet endorsement yesterday to operate as a commercial-free public TV station.


"We consider that 1.5 per cent from the sin tax, no more than Bt2 billion, should be enough for TITV's operations," Finance Minister Chalongphop Sussangkarn told reporters.


"The working committee estimated that 1.5 per cent would be about Bt1.5 billion, as annual tobacco and alcohol excise-tax collection is about Bt100 billion," he said.


TITV's financing would follow the model for the Thai Health Promotion Foundation, which was set up in 2001 outside the bureaucratic process by the Health Promotion Foundation Act, he said.


ThaiHealth runs on an annual budget of Bt2 billion from excise taxes on alcohol and tobacco products.


The allocation for TITV would not cause difficulties for the treasury, as the amount is deemed not too high nor too little, he said.


This is an extraordinary case, he said. The Finance Ministry normally would not agree to any law that directs the use of tax revenue, but this is a special case for better social balance.


The Thai Government has its priorities straight. It can find the money to broadcast more government propaganda and produce horrible quality programming for another public TV station, yet no money to finance the public health system, particularly for foreign drugs.


Friday, April 20, 2007

Junta Allededly Using State Money to Hire Cronies to Produce Anti-Thaksin Propaganda

Thaksin supporters targeting CNS again


Bangkok Post


Say vested interests at work in TV campaign


YUWADEE TUNYASIRI & WASSANA NANUAM


Supporters of ousted prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra have renewed their attacks on the Council for National Security (CNS), accusing it of having vested interests in the budget allocated for a new public relations campaign. The anti-coup website www.hi-thaksin.org yesterday published an article attacking the CNS for hiring a firm to produce a documentary highlighting the reasons for staging the Sept 19 coup that ousted the Thaksin government.


The writer of the article, using the pen name ''Pradab'', produced copies of a four-page official memo by the CNS' public relations office seeking 2.25 million baht to create the documentary to be aired on a television programme, ''Tomorrow Must Be Better''.


Assistant army chief and key CNS member Gen Anupong Paochinda approved the memo, submitted on Jan 31 this year, according to the writer.


According to the memo, the documentary would contain 75 segments, each two minutes long. Each segment would cost 30,000 baht to produce.


The author queried the hiring of a private firm to make the programme, saying it was unnecessary for the army to outsource as it had Channel 5 to do the job.


The CNS was only trying to find an excuse to hire a certain private firm with close ties to it, the author said.


The article said airtime fees were not explained in the memo, indicating a possible attempt to cover up the real cost of production.


The writer said it was a waste of state money to run such a television programme, and suspected that the job of producing the documentary might be given to Chianchuang Kalayanamitr, a younger brother of assistant army chief Gen Saprang, who is deputy secretary-general of the CNS.


The CNS was earlier taken to task over the 12 million baht PR contract it granted to a team led by Mr Chianchuang.


The CNS denied any hidden agenda and maintained that it was possible to produce the documentary at a very cheap price, including the airtime fee.


Assistant army-chief-of-staff Jariya Thongthap, head of the CNS' public relations centre, said the Chianchuang team had nothing to do with running the programme.


''We have hired a small public relations team which is professional to handle the programme. We have to accept that we, soldiers, have no ability to do it,'' he said. Lt-Gen Jariya refused to identify the team.


He believed the person who handed the official memo to CNS opponents was the same person who earlier leaked the Chianchuang contract to the public.


The junta has control over all state media. It has the newspapers and Thai academics in its pocket. The Nation pumps the airwaves with its anti-Thaksin propaganda everyday. TiTV is now a mouthpiece for the junta. So why does it keep going to independent producers to produce anti-Thaksin propaganda?

Monday, April 16, 2007

The Bangkok Post's Scathing Editorial Against Coup Makers and Their Paid Backers

Editorial

The Bangkok Post

Virtue never can be bought

For a regime that promised transparency and accountability, the ruling Council for National Security (CNS) has showed little of either. Like a dentist pulling teeth, the media and citizens' groups have slowly been prying out details on some very questionable operations. Far from coming clean even when found out, the military has sought refuge in the cover-up. More troubling is its recent reflex of raw intimidation. Even the government has been used to issue threats to silence those who want authorities to live up to their six-month-old promise of openness.


The latest questionable project unearthed is a planned propaganda campaign against the deposed Thaksin Shinawatra regime. The documents first surfaced on a Thaksin-friendly website, but quickly were copied and under close scrutiny on Bangkok-based Internet chatrooms.


The CNS went through the tiring ritual of an embarrassed junta unable to keep its own secrets. First came denial; the papers were a forgery. Then came anger; someone must pay for stealing secret documents, and websites hosting discussions might have to be closed.


Then came PR management attempts; the papers were just normal routine for a new regime worried about a Thaksin comeback.


It now is clear that the documents, stolen or not, are authentic. They detail a shocking effort to secretly use 12 million baht to buy or rent some of the country's most influential voices in a partisan political campaign manipulated by the military. They claim to have lined up several leading politicians and academics to attack Thai Rak Thai and the Thaksin circle _ not out of conviction that it was best for the country, but for a share of the 12 million baht. One is torn between what is the sadder military claim: That influential voices can be bought, or that they can be bought so cheaply.


At the centre of the purloined papers is a familiar figure: CNS Assistant Army chief and CNS deputy secretary-general Saprang Kalayanamitr. Just over a month ago, Gen Saprang was on the front pages after his seven-million-baht European tour. Unsurprisingly, neither he, his superiors nor the military-appointed government have accounted for that trip. Now, Gen Saprang's younger brother Chianchuang has turned up as the head of the secret, 12-million-baht propaganda effort.


Secretariat director Gen Somjet Boonthanom, who keeps the CNS budget and signs the expense vouchers, says 12 million baht isn't much. He has a point that Mr Thaksin's populist policies cost more. Of course, a regime that has to purchase simulated support probably cannot survive for long anyhow.


But he is wrong in his claim: 12 million secret baht to purchase influence is a huge amount. And there is much about the overall plan that is still unknown, let alone the details. Leaked documents, for example, claim that the military felt it could buy off ''third parties including local and international media networks, both publicly and secretly''.


Perhaps they could, perhaps not.


The propaganda plan, now in tatters, was exposed and ridiculed in the exact media that the military planned to subvert. But while Thai newspapers and many websites have uncovered the basic plan, it should be noted that the CNS also was specifically targetting broadcast media as an outlet for their information campaign against Mr Thaksin and his cronies. That branch of media remains under military control that is tighter than at any time in the past 15 years.


Academics and the leading opposition parties who were supposedly to be the front men for the military propaganda also have been mostly silent in the wake of accusations that their opinions and influence were for sale, and for a low price at that.


CNS statements to the contrary, conceiving and launching this disinformation campaign was worse than stealing and publicising it.


The government and the military are expected to publicise their achievements, and to criticise opponents. The media and country would welcome any such information. It is unacceptable that the CNS would hire cronies and insiders with taxpayer money. But then, a virtuous regime would never have to resort to purchasing support.


Looks like The Bangkok Post didn't pick up any checks. But I wonder about The Nation. Even though it was has been critical of Surayud, it hasn't criticized the junta that much, especially Generals Sonthi and Saparang, and there is no doubt that The Nation has been vociferously anti-Thaksin. As for the corruption allegations against the junta, it only reports whatever PTV discovers, ironically Also, since the coup, Suthichai and Thongchai have become ubiquitous on Thai TV. Personally, I think they have been "rewarded" for their loyalty to their junta, but that is only my opinion.

As for the other "journalists" and "academics," it doesn't surprise me that they sold their opinions in exchange for money from the junta. Most Thai journalists and academics don't have any integrity to begin with.

But to be fair, I hope that The Bangkok Post would have the decency to actually interview these people who were allegedly bought off. They should be given the opportunity to issue denials.


Kudos to Bangkok Pundit for his blogging on this topic. He really has done an excellent job.

Wednesday, April 11, 2007

Who's Who of Political Insiders and Academics on Junta's Payroll

Saprang's cousin given PR work 'because of experience'

The Nation


The cousin of a key junta figure was chosen to head a Bt12-million government public relations campaign because "he is a professional and experienced at PR," Council for National Security (CNS) spokesman Colonel Sansern Kaewkamnerd said yesterday.

Chianchuang Kalayanamitr is a cousin of CNS deputy secretary-general Saprang. Sansern said the CNS could bargain with Chianchuang also because his was well-known to them. "We were able to reduce the budget from Bt25 million to Bt12 million because we could negotiate the hire," he said, after a CNS meeting yesterday.


The anti-coup website www.hi-thaksin.org claimed yesterday that several well-known politicians were part of the Bt12-million PR team. It reported earlier this week that a team led by Chianchuang had been hired for the PR campaign. The documents were signed by CNS chairman Sonthi Boonyaratglin on Feb 4.


Chianchuang has admitted taking the the work, but denied it had anything to do with Saprang.


The military, meanwhile, were trying to find the person who leaked the information, claiming the leak was a violation of the law, as the document was highly confidential.


The hi-Thaksin website has continued attacking the CNS, hinting on Monday they had more information on Chianchuang's team. Yesterday, it had a report titled "Disclosure of the Chianchuang Gangsters".


It claimed there are over 100 PR staff members. Most are academics and politicians critical of the Thaksin government, including former Chat Pattana party leader Korn Dabbaransi, Democrats Korn Chatikavanij, Alongkorn Palabutr and Korbsak Sabavasu, Prapat Panya-chatraksa, a key Thai Rak Thai member who moved to the Chat Thai party, plus ex-senator Kraisak Choonhavan. Academics included Wuttipong Piebjriya-wat, Sophon Supapong, Narong Phet-prasert, Somkiat Osotspa.However, Sophon denied he had anything to do with the project.


Wow, what a list of people on the junta's payroll.

I'm a little surprised how cheaply they sold their souls for.

But this list accurately reflects the chorus of voices the last six months that have been outspoken against Thaksin and pro-junta.

Tuesday, April 10, 2007

Bangkok Post: CNS Wants to Punish Leaker of their Propaganda Slush Fund

CNS hunts for people behind leak

PR project papers were classified


Bangkok Post

WASSANA NANUAM

The Council for National Security (CNS), which has been criticised over a 12-million-baht budget for public relations given to a younger brother of a key member, is trying to nail the source of the leak of the classified information to the public.

CNS vice-chairman and air force commander-in-chief ACM Chalit Pukpasuk said yesterday that anyone who had released the information would be considered to have violated the law, because it was highly confidential.

ACM Chalit denied any knowledge of the reported spending but said public relations campaigns were normal activities of any state agencies, and spending for this purpose was legitimate.

Chalit: Spending on PR is legitimate

The CNS hired a team led by Chianchuang Kalayanamitr to take responsibility for the public relations campaign.

Mr Chianchuang is a younger brother of assistant army chief Gen Saprang, who is secretary-general to the CNS.

Continued


The absurdity never ends. If this is normal behavior of a government agency, why keep it a secret?

Also, it looks like General Saprang is cashing in, the guy who considered himself the savior of the country.

He spent $175,000 on a week long trip to Europe for him and his cronies, and now his brother gets 12 million, roughly $330,000, for a secret propaganda campaign against Thaksin, which apparently hasn't worked at all.

The propaganda campaign may have not stopped Thaksin, but General Saprang has done a fairly good job of silencing the media in relation to the problems at the airport ever since he took over at AOT.

Sunday, April 8, 2007

Bangkok Post: Illegal CNS Uses Taxpayer's Money to Attack Thaksin

CNS' anti-Thaksin campaign

Bangkok Post

The Council for National Security (CNS) has allocated a 12-million-baht budget for a public relations campaign to counter deposed prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra's attempts to discredit the coup-makers, a source said yesterday.

The request for the money was submitted on Jan 24 and was approved by CNS chairman Sonthi Boonyaratkalin.

The budget has been divided into six portions of two million baht each to finance the campaign's operations covering a period of six months, the source said.

Chianchuang Kalayanamitr, a younger brother of CNS deputy secretary-general Saprang Kalayanamitr, has been appointed head of the publicity team to make sure it turns out to be a successful campaign, the source said.

The campaign aims to pre-empt Mr Thaksin's attempts to sully the reputation of the coup-makers via his lawyer Noppadol Pattama, said the source.

The first month of the campaign in February was spent on explaining to the public the negative effects "Thaksinomics" has had on the country.

Seminars and discussions were held, essays and articles were written and published in the media to shed light on the mistakes of the previous government, such as the controversial privatisation of state enterprises - one of the signature policies of the Thaksin administration, said the source.


The junta uses the tax payer's money to purchase propaganda from academic and media professionals to attack Thaksin, the legal prime minister of Thailand, for attacking the illegally installed junta using a general's brother who just got back from an expensive overseas trip on the tax payer's dime.

Amazing Thailand


Thursday, February 8, 2007

Deconstructing Sanitsuda Ekachai: Chief Hypocrite of the Bangkok Post

Media's noble principles and reality


If we are unhappy with the global media's coverage in favour of Thaksin Shinawatra and accuse them of being out of touch with the local reality and sentiment, it should make us also rethink our own media's values and practices. The media, global or local, like to advertise themselves as value-free. Objectivity, they say, is their mode of operation and truth is their goal. We all know, however, that the there is a big disparity between reality and the media's noble principles.


If anything, the positive coverage of Mr Thaksin by the Western, global media only reiterates their firm, unchanging support for corporate-led globalisation. No matter who is in power, they will get the Western media's support as long as they are willing to open their country for investment and financial transactions that benefit their investors.


Here comes the anti-globalization, anti-West bullshit. What is the relationship between Thaksin's interviews with media outlets ranging from Asahi Shimbun to CNN and Time to Al-Jazeera and "corporate led globalization?" There is no evidence that these news agencies are interviewing Thaksin because he is good for international capitalists from those countries hosting those news agencies, and there is no evidence of collusion between those news agencies and international corporations heavily invested in Thailand. Besides, Thailand is a third-tier country for Western capital. Look at any financial portfolio of any fund manager who invests in the developing world. Many could care less about Thailand. In terms of FDI, Western capital is not as hot about Thailand compared to other countries, because of the dismal education standards, bad English skills, and low productivity of the Thais. In other words, no companies are trying to tear down Thailand's walls to get in and exploit it. That is a right-wing myth that has been perpetuated by the brain dead of the Thai intelligentsia for a long time. Also, if the West had such a love affair with Thaksin because of his pro-Western capitalist policies, the SET would have dropped like a ton of bricks after the coup.


And if Sanitsuda doesn't want foreign capital in Thailand, why doesn't she start a political movement to get rid of it in Thailand?


She can start with the foreigners who advertise in the Bangkok Post, then move on to the foreigners who purchase the newspaper. After, she can start a movement to eliminate tourism, then foreign direct investment. I dare her to make an announcement in her column.


Why doesn't she put into action what she preaches?


But I guarantee Sanitsuda will continue to hypocritically lecture from her columnist's perch about the evils of the West while continuing to benefit from all of its material progress.


If wasn't for the West, ungrateful Sanitsuda wouldn't have a job as a journalist, because the evil farang are responsible for introducing newspapers and the electronic into Thailand. Before the farang came to Thailand, most Thai women were illiterate and couldn't read. Before the farang and global capital, there was no education-no public schools or universities. Sanitsuda should look around. Every material comfort that she has was developed by evil farang capitalists.


Sanitsuda should be kissing the feet of Western capitalists. Otherwise, where would she be without them? She would be out in the fields in the hot sun twelve hours a day half naked shucking rice, as well as being a slave to her husband, who without the enlightenment of Western values could sell her and her childen into slavery any time he wished.



Remember how we were so frustrated with the Democrat government for bowing to the pressures from the IMF after the economic meltdown, and how we embraced Mr Thaksin's policy to rescue national pride?


Yes. We remember that right-wing bullshit.

Backing the Democrats' pro-IMF stance and suspicion of Mr Thaksin's populist platforms, the Western media severely bashed Mr Thaksin's economic policy for fear of him turning Thailand inward economically.


Yes, that happened.


It turned out to an empty fear. The telecom tycoon soon made it clear that he believes money has no nationality and no boundaries should exist for big players. That's how he has become the darling of the Western investors and the Western press, given their support for free trade and investment which works in their favour.


More lies and bullshit. When has Thaksin ever become a darling of the Western media? Where is one article or TV interview with one Western news outlet that proves this Western love fest for Thaksin? I love this right-wing reactionary bullshit line: The West was in love with Thaksin because he was selling the country out to Western capitalists. This is has been the standard right-wing nationalist mantra going back for decades.


Where is the evidence?


Sanitsuda is a shameless liar.


It does not matter if the poor will suffer from free but unfair trade. It does not matter if the national leader was abusing his power to write new rules and regulations so his companies and those of his cronies benefited from them. It does not matter if he incited violence and ethnic hatred that spun out of control. It does matter if he is a liar. As long as he is still supporting corporate-led globalisation while the clumsy junta in Thailand appears increasingly nationalistic and inward-looking, they will continue to allow Mr Thaksin to use their publications to lie to the world.


Has Sanitsuda been taking right-wing nationalist lessons from The Nation's editors? The Bangkok Post allowed Thaksin to use its newspapers to lie and scam the Thai people for six years. Where was the condemnation of Thaksin in the Bangkok Post during those six years while he was doing those horrible things to the country? Sanitsuda is a shameless hypocrite. Further, the Bangkok Post sold out its journalistic integrity when it turned into the Thaksin government's puppet and whored itself for advertising revenue instead of confronting him.


But is the Thai national media free of the same sin? When it comes to objectivity and concern for local sentiment, can we say we are holier?If we accuse the Western media of being pro corporate-led globalisation, haven't our mainstream media always been a blind supporter of ruthless economic development? It does not matter how destructive it is to the environment and the locals' way of life. It does not matter how it makes the rich richer and the poor poorer _ as long as the city people and businesses benefit from it.


This idiotic woman doesn't know who pays her bills. Look how she jumps on the feudal socialist bandwagon. I wonder what type of house she owns, the car she drives, the TV she watches, the computer she uses, the mobile phone she babbles into, and every other gadget that she uses which is a product of capitalism. I wonder if she lives the sufficiency lifestyle while accepting the money from the endless ads that finance the publishing of her newspaper.


Upholding growth-oriented economic development like a religion, our media also allows the government to advertise their mega industrial projects, reporting them as fact while belittling the local villagers as anti-development hillbillies and painting their protests as a nuisance.


When the current buzzword is por piang or sufficiency, we also continue to be the authorities' mouthpiece, failing again to question the junta's use of royal development advice to legitimise their power-grabbing game.


The media, global or local, are not value-free. They are shaped by their own country's vested interests, political ideologies and the businesses. They are influenced by their prejudice, patriotism, fear and a sense of moral superiority. They are also chained by deadlines and business competition which make it hard for them to go beyond the surface of a phenomenon.


When we realise that the media's objectivity is only a myth, we will stop being a passive recipient of news and information. We will stop pinning our hopes for change on the media and start taking things into our hands.


That is when the media will have to wake up to their mission, the pursuit of truth and justice _ or risk becoming irrelevant.


Sanitsuda Ekachai is Assistant Editor, Bangkok Post.

Email: sanitsudae@bangkokpost.co.th


Thai media's noble principles? I suggest the reader go to a magazine stand or sit in front of a TV and read and watch the Thai media in action for at least two days. There is nothing in the Thai media that is principled or noble. Engaging the Thai media is like giving oneself a lobotomy.



What is so outrageous about this column is that this woman clearly benefits from everything she condemns. The Bangkok Post is clearly a product of globalized world. She is a Thai writing for an English language newspaper that serves an international audience and accepts advertising from multi-national corporations.


I don't see her announcing that she quitting her job and going to live a subsistence lifestyle with the peasants.

I don't see her leading the revolution against materialism and ridding Thailand of farang capitalists.

Nation/Junta Propaganda War Against Thaksin Jumps into First Gear

'Traitor' used to describe Thaksin


Saprang launches barrage of vitriol at former PM, says he has a cell for him


A junta member yesterday made a veiled attack against ousted prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra who criticised the royal thinking on the sufficiency economy theory, saying the true colours of a traitor would prove to be his own downfall.


"The traitor is slated to be banished to live forever in the jungle because there is no place in society for a deceitful politician," Council for National Security (CNS) assistant secretary-general Saprang Kalayanamitra said, without mentioning any names.


Saprang spoke to a group of 1,000 local politicians, government officials and community leaders, rallying them to assist in uprooting the legacy of the ousted government.


He was on a tour of north-eastern provinces as part of a CNS campaign against the deposed regime.


"Civil servants should know they are dispensing duties on His Majesty's behalf, so they are not supposed to allow themselves to become henchmen for rogue politicians," he said.



90 Thai embassies to rebut Thaksin: Nitya


The government has asked diplomats to counter comments made by deposed prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra in interviews with world news media organisations.


Thaksin has made comments critical of the junta and its government in recent broadcasts and publications.


The government is asking diplomats at more than 90 embassies to correct misinterpretations, Foreign Minister Nitya Pibulsonggram said Wednesday.



Nation's Propaganda War Against the US and US Media Outlets Continue

Democrats: Why did Thaksin hire firm?


Democrat Party executive Korbsak Sabhavasu yesterday called on the United States to clarify its position on ousted prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra who has recently hired a powerful lobbying firm, in which former Secretary of State James Baker III is a senior partner, to monitor Washington's policy towards the military-backed government.


The lobbying registration on the US Senate website confirmed that Thaksin had hired Baker Botts LLP, with an effective date of December 11, 2006. Baker was the US Secretary of State during the Bush Snr administration.


American Ambassador to Bangkok, Ralph Boyce, downplayed the hiring of the firm, saying lobbying firms and the US government are two separate entities.


"Anybody has a right to hire a lobbyist. It is a transparent system in the US. It has to be registered. So far, this has nothing to do with the US government," Boyce said.


Other officials said Thaksin's hiring lobbying firms in the US might be a big news story in Thailand, but in Washington DC, such a move is a "non-issue".


According to the registration, Baker Botts was hired to help "develop and implement a strategic approach to the various international legal and political issues that confront Dr Thaksin as a result of the coup of September 19".


"The firm will monitor the evolution of US policies towards the interim government in Thailand or the Administration's position regarding attempts by Dr Thaksin to return to Thailand and may subsequently undertake contacts as necessary to ensure that such policies remain consistent with those currently in place."


Speaking to the media, Korbsak questioned Thaksin's true intention with the hiring of the Baker Botts lobbying firm.

In the registration form under "general description of client's business or activities" Thaksin was described as "the freely elected Prime Minister of Thailand".


Thaksin's lawyer in Bangkok, Noppodol Patama, was quick to remind Korbsak that he had left out the word "deposed" in reference to Thaksin.


Foreign Ministry spokesman Kitti Wasinond, meanwhile, said the government was not in a position to call on Baker Botts to deny their service to Thaksin.


"It is the right of an individual to hire a lobbyist," Kitti said, adding, "I believe that the US will continue its good relations and co-operation with Thailand."


Thaksin has jolted the political leaders in Bangkok with his relentless attacks against the military-backed government and the junta that ousted him.


Besides Baker Botts, Thaksin has also hired Barbour Griffith and Rogers LLP. According to the US Senate lobbying registration, the firm was hired to "Provide guidance and counsel with regard to Mr Thaksin's interest in Washington, DC, and abroad."


He has also enlisted Edelman, a public relations firm, to handle his international publicity, resulting in numerous interviews with the international media, including CNN, The Wall Street Journal, Time Asahi Shimbun, the Kyodo News Agency and a string of others.


Thaksin earlier this week said he would give interviews to the Thai media but reversed his decision yesterday, his lawyer Noppodol said.


Thai publications had been considering whether to dispatch senior reporters and editors, especially those critical of Thaksin, to interview him. Noppodol did not explain why Thaksin has reversed his decision.


In an interview with Al Jazeera television network broadcast on Tuesday, Thaksin called on the junta to end their rule.


"They have to return power to the people. They cannot hold power forever," Thaksin said.


The former premier said the coup had divided the Thai people and he vowed to help reconcile their differences.


Thaksin, who led Thailand for six years, was accused of being grossly corrupt and divisive.


I have already started to document how The Nation and other Thai media figures, Nongnuch Singhadecha of Matichon, have started to turn this Thaksin/Junta media war into your typical blame America for all of Thailand's problems session. Recently, the Thai Journalists Association wrote a nasty letter to Time Magazine condemning its interview with Thaksin. Yet it didn't write a similar letter to Al Jazeera. How come? Why the double standards?


Notice how The Nation chose to intentionally attack American news outlets, while never criticizing Japanese(Kyoto, Asahi Shimbub) and Arab news(Al Jazeera) outlets for interviewing Thaksin.


Now a member of the Democrat Party is on the blame the US bandwagon. And it will only spread and get worst, because this is what the Thai media and politicians do when they have no Thais to blame.


I'm not happy that three US lobbying firms are representing Thaksin, but that is his right and it is their right. Plus, official US policy and private lobbying are two different things. Unfortunately, the Thai media will exploit the ignorance of the Thai public concerning their knowledge of the US political system. If you don't believe me, follow the Thai media the next few weeks and see what happens.


The Nation should really be ashamed of itself. First, it started a propaganda war with Singapore and now it is going after the US. Who will it go next when everybody has been exhausted?


Also, notice the sloppy reporting of The Nation. Not one reporter has actually called any of these lobbying firms to confirm. The Nation is using information they get off a website. What kind of shitty reporting is this? Are they afraid of calling these lobbying firms because nobody on staff can speak English? The Nation wants to start a propaganda war and they are playing bullshit games with the facts. No right-thinking editor would use a website as verification in a story if it was possible to get direct confirmation from the source itself. And where are the quotes from the lobbying firms? This is total bullshit reporting and The Nation knows it is bullshit.


For any of my American readers out there, let me tell you that this type of propaganda is intentional. The Thai media and some politicians have a long history of making the US the scapegoat for Thailand's problems.


On a personal note, I actually contacted one of these lobbying firms and begged them not to take Thaksin as a client, because I knew that the Thai media would start attacking the US government for things that US lobbyists were doing. I predicted that the Thai media would start a media war with the US and hurt Thai-US relations.


I don't care if you are anti-Thaksin or pro-Thaksin or anti-US or pro-US, it is not right to make the US a scapegoat for the absurdity of Thai politics. If you are American, I urge you to do what you can to help me nip this nonsense in the bud.

Contact the US Embassy in Bangkok or your US Congressmen. This bullshit needs to stop.


Tuesday, February 6, 2007

Authoritarian China Backs Thai Military Junta Over Keeping Thaksin Quiet in Exile

China promises not to allow Thaksin attack Thailand

China will not allow deposed Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra to use its territory as a launch pad to attack Thailand and Thai citizens, Chinese ambassador to Bangkok Zhang Jiuhuan said Tuesday.

"As an alliance, China will not allow anybody to use our territory to oppose Thailand and Thai citizens. China will not interfere domestic affairs of any countries," Zhang told Nation Channel.


Notice how the word Thaksin is missing from this statement.


The programme will be aired on Siam This Morning on Channel 5 at 6:15am Wednesday.


Thaksin was ousted by a military coup in September but remains worrisome for the people in power in Bangkok as he continue with his relentless attacks against the government from various cities around the world.


Relentless attacks? More Nation propaganda bullshit.


Thaksin is reportedly in the process of setting up a China-based satellite television network to sustain his assault against the government.


The Council for National Security (CNS) was irked by Thaksin's latest interview, which appeared in a recent edition of Time magazine's Asia edition in which he made a reference to the monarchy. Thaksin told Time that the Thai people threw their support behind the coup after it was endorsed by HM the King.


Local media portrayed the comment as an offensive remark to the monarchy.


The junta accused Thaksin of trying to link the monarchy to the coup, an allegation that they consistently denied.


Every government since His Majesty the King ascended the throne has been "endorsed" by him in one way or another. Where else does the government derive its authority? The coup certainly didn't have democratic mandate. Thailand will never be a democratic country if it continues with the charades and bullshit.


Zhang said however, Chinese authorities were not aware of Thaksin's new plan, said Zhang.


When asked if Beijing would order private sector who run the television to bar Thaksin from broadcasting his message against the junta, the ambassador replied indirectly that China is a sovereign country with full authority to enforce its law.


Now here comes the Chinese bullshit.


Thaksin was overseas when the coup occurred and has not been allowed to return since. He has traveled to UK, China, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Singapore, Japan and Australia to state his case.


More Nation bullshit. In how many countries and how often has Thaksin stated his case?


Talking freely with journalists in those countries, he has insisted he has no intention to return to politics but also expressed confidence that he could win an election if he chose to run.


So what?


The ambassador Zhang said China could not bar Thaksin from entering the China, saying he has the same privilege as other Thai nationals.


"As long as we are unable to reject entry of Thai citizens, we are also unable to bar him from entering China, be it for tourism or else," Zhang said.


"I hope Thai people would understand. We will not allow anybody to spoil relations of the two countries as he has not met any Chinese officials," Zhang said.


Where did the Chinese take bullshit lessons from? Meeting officials and launching media attacks are not the same thing.


Thaksin has already spoiled diplomatic relations between Thailand and Singapore as the citystate allowed him to meet the country's Deputy Prime Minister S. Jayakumar when he was there last month. The military backed government suspended a number of bilateral meetings with Singapore in retaliation.


I love how The Nation blames bad relations between Singapore and Thailand on Thaksin.


Is the military junta and Chinese government babes in arms? It wouldn't be surprising.


The PRC is the biggest sponsor of murderers and thugs(Burma, North Korea) on the planet, and Thailand is certainly within China's traditional sphere of influence.


Monday, February 5, 2007

More anti-Thaksin Rubbish from The Nation's Obsessed

HARD TALK

Let Thaksin talk - we no longer have to listen

Should we jump every time Thaksin Shinawatra gives an interview? Is the political manoeuvring of the former prime minister consuming too much of our energy?

The Nation does jump every time Thaksin appears in the international media. He does consume too much of your energy.

It's probably about time that we deny Thaksin the fun that he has been having with all the attention given to his global criss-crossing and interviews. After all, what is so enlightening or earth-shaking about all the things he has said to the international media anyway?

There is nothing enlightening or earth-shaking about what he says--except when the staff at The Nation get their panties all bunched up when he talks about sufficiency or the king. Then The Nation staff puts on their yellow shirts and goes to see King Naresuan to make themselves feel better, or they just write ill-informed nasty columns about the dastardly foreign media that is so in love with Thaksin. I'm just surprised that The Nation hasn't started to blame the US yet. Oh, wait, look below.

The fact that Thaksin has been featured on the cover of the Asian edition of Time magazine and in an interview on CNN (by the way, both belong to the Time Warner group) does not in any way mean that the former leader has suddenly become a darling of the international media, much less a signal that he is on the verge of a political comeback as his opponents may fear.

Funny, all week long all your buddies have been saying that Thaksin has become the darling of the foreign media. Don't you and Thanong ever chat? You guys don't discuss how Time-Warner and Temasek are in cahoots to take over Thailand, starting with the most glorious Nation Multimedia Empire.

And the generals in the Council for National Security (CNS) should stop fooling themselves or the media here that there is a conspiracy out there to keep Thaksin in the spotlight. The international media talk to Thaksin simply because he is still an interesting interview subject. The Thai media would have wanted to sit down and talk to him too, had they been given a chance.

No, they talk to Thaksin because they paid a couple PR firms to get his message out. Why do I have to keep repeating myself? Normally, Thaksin is a horrible subject and nobody in the world could care two shits about Thailand. Do you guys think Thaksin or Thailand sells magazines? Gimme a break. The Thai media should talk to Thaksin. That is their duty as journalists. But that is something The Nation would know nothing about.

But Thaksin somehow finds the international media easier to manipulate. Being a journalist with Time or CNN doesn't mean being able to pose better questions than Thai reporters could. If those journalists didn't ask probing questions or chose to skirt around issues crucial to Thais, it was either because they have to cater to an international audience or simply because they are ignorant.

I love this little snarky attack against the international media, as if the Thai media has its shit together. The Thai media, including The Nation, literally allowed Thaksin to get away with murder for 6 years. It did nothing to investigate him or his regime. And when has a Thai journalist ever asked Thaksin(or any politician) a tough question? They always threw him softballs, much worse than the idiots at CNN or at Time. Look at the bullshit interview with Prasong as evidence of a crappy interview or the interview with Mahathir. Thepchai, you are the last journalist in the world who should be criticizing the international media. Where the fuck is your Pulitzer Prize?

For the audience, here is a special treat. You can witness the interviewing prowess of Thailand's most illustrious journalist:

Thepchai's interview with Dr. Mahathir Part 1 Part 2

Could Thepchai kiss Dr. Mahathir's ass any more than this?

Thaksin's Interview with CNN


And because Thaksin has an international forum doesn't mean that he can count on it to cast himself in a better light. Don't forget that Thaksin was not the only deposed political strongman in the region to be featured on the cover of Time. Ferdinand Marcos of the Philippines and Suharto of Indonesia made the cover long before him, after they too were chased out of power. So there is no special treatment being given to Thaksin, as some in the CNS suspect.

Thaksin is doing a pretty good job of spinning his message. Thaksin is getting special treatment by the media, because normally nobody cares about him. He was disliked as PM and he is disliked now. Now he just has good spin doctors.


What has irked the CNS generals and the Surayud government has more to do with what Thaksin said than the fact that he was being given prominent coverage. But it would be foolish to expect Thaksin to suddenly turn over a new leaf and start being nice to the generals who overthrew him and the new government led by someone whom he had seen as a potential threat to his political longevity all along.

Of course, this is common sense.

The best way to deal with Thaksin is to stop worrying about what he has to say. The American lobbying firm that he hired may be able to get some of the international media interested in him for a while. But it's only a matter of time before Thaksin fades from media attention. After all, he is nowhere near being a political icon or a deposed leader known for taking a stand on democratic principles, which would have kept the media interested in his every move.

The best way to deal with Thaksin is for the generals to get their own American spin doctors and tear him a new asshole. The generals have all the resources of the state to go after Thaksin. They can even confiscate his money to attack him. This is what I would do: If there is evidence that the generals have of Thaksin doing crimes but can't reveal it to the Thai press or the Thai public for whatever reasons, give it to the international press, then the Thai press can reprint that material. If there is no evidence against Thaksin, then why did they list corruption as one of the reasons to depose him? If Thaksin is not a threat, why are the generals uneasy? Are they waiting for him to come back so they all can cut a deal? Like, for example, Thaksin pays off all the generals in exchange for keeping his freedom and staying out of politics? In other words, Thai justice for the rich.


General Sonthi Boonyaratglin, the CNS chairman and leader of the September 19 coup, couldn't hide his paranoia when he confided to the Thai media that he suspected Thaksin's interview with CNN two weeks ago was part of the conspiracy he has orchestrated against the junta. But just because he was asked some sensitive questions doesn't mean that his interviewer had a hidden agenda.

I love these codes that Thai journalists use, as if their audience knows what they are talking about. Thais are notorious plagiarizers, so it doesn't surprise me when they never quote any sources. Excuse me: How are we supposed to know what this means? Seriously, you guys should stop exploiting your farang copy writers and pay them more money. The editing has been really bad lately.

The generals should learn to educate themselves on how the international media work so that they will not have to cry out every time they read or hear Thaksin's comments. The only way they can silence Thaksin or render his arguments irrelevant is to make sure that the investigations into the former leader's misdeeds produce results as soon as possible.

I don't hear the generals crying as much as The Nation. Why doesn't The Nation do its job and investigate Thaksin's crimes? That is what the media does in the civilized world. In the US, the media actually does most of the investigating. It, unlike the Thai media, doesn't wait for orders from the government. Let us look at this for a moment. Would any serious news organization in the West wait for the investigation of military dictatorship to finish, so that they could print the results without question. You guys at The Nation make a mockery out of the profession of journalism.

Thaksin may have all the money in the world to pay for an American lobbying firm to make noises on his behalf, but his wealth cannot change the fact that he is politically finished and his chances of a comeback are almost nil.

Thaksin always has the chance of coming back if they majority of people support him. I know it is hard for The Nation to get this, but sometimes in a democracy you might actually be on the losing side. It sucks, but that is democracy. But I don't expect The Nation to get that, since it is the only media outlet in the world that intentionally allies itself with a military dictatorship. The Nation staff should really give up being journalists and go upcountry and live on a farm. There, they can live as subsistence farmers to their hearts content and sing the praises of sufficiency economy until their throats hurt.

That Thaksin is extending an invitation to the Thai media to interview him after having ignored them for months is only a sign that he is becoming desperate. And he knows too well that all the publicity he has been creating outside Thailand is not helping him in any way here.

Thaksin is playing you all for fools. He is tenacious and ruthless. He has declared war. But you guys at The Nation are too idiotic to realize it.

The Bangkok Post Has Really Jumped the Shark

Foreign media loves Thaksin

The Bangkok Post has lost its marbles. There is not one shred of evidence that the "foreign press loves Thaksin." In fact, the foreign press went after Thaksin time and time again during his tenure, especially when he was espousing National Socialist Thaksinomics which, by the way, really isn't that distinguishable from National Socialist juntanomics. They also went after him about killings in the South, the extra-judicial killings during the drug war, his handling of Sars and the bird flu, and his delusions of regional grandeur.

Note: The Al Jazeera piece seemed pro-Thaksin to me. But the Bangkok Post and Nation are ignoring it.


Like it or not, exiled former prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra still manages to manipulate the media for his own vested interests, at home and abroad.

At home in Thailand, the press conference held almost weekly - usually on weekends when there are few newsworthy events - by his faithful mouthpiece, Noppadon Pattama, attracts a big crowd of newshounds. They tend to unhesitantly report whatever he says, mostly about his boss' good points, which are laughable to most seasoned observers.

Where was the Bangkok Post during Thaksin's tenure? It was cowering in fear of being sued from Thaksin and his crony agents. The same newspaper that was firing editors and reporters at the command of Thaksin and his agents. Now that Thaksin is gone, it seems The Nation and Bangkok Post have found some courage. So much courage, in fact, that they haven't printed any evidence uncovering Thaksin's nefarious empire. Who are the bureaucrats covering for Thaksin? If the Bangkok Post knows so much, why isn't it producing receipts? Why isn't it naming names? Why isn't it putting a fire under the asses of those bureaucrats who are covering for Thaksin? When will it stop being sarcastic and start producing facts? When will the Bangkok Post stop acting like a petulant 3rd World worthless tabloid and grow up act like a responsible member of the international media community?


Here are just two examples of the incredible statements coming from Noppadon's mouth: One, Thaksin wholeheartedly favours a free press in Thailand. This was in direct response to the threat to gag the media by the Council for National Security (CNS). And two, Thaksin fully supports the sufficiency economy advocated by His Majesty the King.


1. We all know that Thaksin is a notorious liar. 2. We all know that Thaksin is a notorious liar. But Thaksin is no bigger of a hypocrite than those in the Thai media who drool over themselves in praise of sufficiency theory--even though these media outlets are the biggest pushers of crass commercialism in Thailand.


While in exile, the globetrotting ex-premier has often been in the news. The foreign media's love affair with Thaksin puzzles many Thais, me included. Especially in recent days, when a number of articles appeared in foreign publications such as The Economist, Asian Wall Street Journal and Newsweek praising the ex-premier and Thaksinomics, while pouring scorn on the coup makers and the Surayud government. Not even the sufficiency economy was spared the foreign media's wrath. Their attacks cast doubt among many that their relationship with Thaksin is strictly professional.


Thaksin hired two extremely capable PR firms, paying them millions of dollars to get his message out. Doesn't The Bangkok Post know how the media works? Or does it live in its own oblivious little Thai world where they think everything is done in a half-assed Thai way, like this column? If the junta hired outside help, they could achieve the same effect, but they are either too arrogant or too stupid to hire outside experts and play hard ball in the international media. What does The Bangkok Post and The Nation editorial staff expect to achieve by snickering away how much the foreign media "loves" and "praises" Thaksin? Do those feelings of right-wing nationalism give them satisfaction? If they want to feel that type of satisfaction, they should put on their Village Scouts uniforms and do a marathon watching of King Naresuan, Bang Rajan and Suryiothai, and when done with that, put on their yellow shirts and watch a Thai-Singapore football match.

The Economist, in its Jan 13 edition, criticises the sufficiency economy. In an article, it blames the Surayud government's support of the sufficiency economy for making foreign firms think Thailand is rejecting globalisation. It cited the imposition of capital controls in early January. It also chides the UNDP for poor judgement in backing the sufficiency economy while a debate of the merits of the philosophy is nonexistent.

No, it is the Thai government's fault for pursuing anti-foreigner, anti-liberal policies and linking them to King Bumibol's sufficiency theory. It was the Thai government's ineptness that caused these problems.

By the way, where is the debate concerning the merits of sufficiency theory? Or is just another trend that the Thai media is going to goose step behind until it gets boring? One has to wonder where the staff at the Bangkok Post has hidden its stash of Khun Thongdaeng books. Perhaps the Bangkok Post should look into promoting the social and economic theory hidden in those tomes and then go on a right-wing tirade against the foreign media imaginary derision of those theories.


Here is an excerpt of the article:

''Perhaps it makes sense for the new government to obscure its predecessor's achievements while stealing its best clothes. The question is why the UNDP thinks it should provide cover for this whitewash by puffing the sufficiency economy as a miracle-cure for the developing world's woes. The answer is that the UNDP is a sucker for this sort of new-age waffle, especially if it has royal patronage. It has also lauded the not entirely dissimilar 'Gross National Happiness' theory of Bhutan's King Jigme Singye Wangchuck.

''In publishing such an unbalanced report on a theory that is untried... the UNDP has abandoned all sense of objectivity. It is also lending legitimacy to a regime that took power by force.''

I beg to differ with the writer's claim about Thaksin's achievements. Perhaps, if the writer had done a little homework he would have realised that the so-called achievements are just an illusion. Did he ever realise how much public debt had been incurred by Thaksin to fulfil his populist schemes that we, the taxpayers, will have to repay? About 150 billion baht in total.

I love how the Bangkok Post plays Monday morning quarterback. How come the Bangkok Post was writing piece after piece about the glories of Thaksinomics when the Thai economy was booming? Remember when the SET went up a hundred percent in one year? I guess the editors have a short memory. And concerning Thailand's debt, there is no way to know the future. Currently, Thailand is in good financial shape. There is absolutely no way to tell if Thaksin was going to bankrupt the country in the future unless you are omnipotent. Further, Thailand's GDP to debt ratio is lower now than before he took power. And the hypocrites at the Bangkok Post have said nothing about the Surayud's massive increases in the budget. By the way, The Economist is a neo-liberal magazine. It doesn't believe in untested feudal socialist theories that make everybody feel warm and fuzzy inside. It believes in empirical evidence and measurable results. Further, the foreign media isn't brainwashed and doesn't have to kow tow to every supposed theory that comes out of the king's mouth. The foreign media, unlike the Thai media, doesn't have any slavish obligations to irrationally and undemocratically supplicate itself to any monarchy.


The country would have gone belly up in debt if Thaksin was allowed to stay on a few more years. The ex-premier and his cronies could then be sunbathing on some faraway beach with all the wealth they accumulated during their years in power.

There is absolutely no evidence to support Thailand going belly up. Thaksin and his cronies can live high on the hog with all their corruption money now if they want. They didn't need to wait for an economic collapse.

''Stealing its best clothes?'' That is a preposterous statement. On the contrary, there may be no clothes left for any of us.

Another lie. Again, no evidence.

Thaksin's achievements? A walk through the Suvarnabhumi airport, his ''mother of all achievements'', is certainly an eye-opener.

Where was the Bangkok Post when the contracts for airport were being handed out? What was the media's responsibility in protecting the interests of the public? Again, the Bangkok Post was cowering in fear like pussies instead of doing its job. Does it have courage now that Thaksin is a million miles away? Unfortunately, it still cowers in fear of Thaksin and his cronies, because it still refuses to investigate like a real newspaper all his dirty shenanigans. Instead, it blames the foreign media for not doing the analysis of Thaksin now that the Thai media repeatedly refused to do while he was in power.


Sufficiency economy is not an economic theory but a philosophy on how to live. Like Buddhism, it preaches moderation and sustainability. It definitely does not reject capitalism or globalisation. For an individual, it means living within his or her means. If someone earns 10,000 baht a month, they should not spend all their earnings or borrow against them by using credit cards.

I love how the Thai media, the biggest pushers of commercialism in the country, have all now found the light in sufficiency theory. The day the Bangkok Post stops printing ads for worthless crap is the day I believe in its sincerity concerning sufficiency theory.

The foreign media can write whatever it wants as there is press freedom here. But a little effort to do better homework is what makes the difference between a good article and a shoddy one.

Veera Prateepchaikul

No, it is the Thai media that has abdicated its responsibilities and has demonstrated nothing but hypocrisy, weakness and irresponsibility. Before blaming the foreign media, the Thai media should do some soul searching and ask what it did wrong with Thaksin and how now it is nothing more than a mouth piece for a military dictatorship. Let's face it. The Thai media has sold out and really has no right to criticize anybody.

Sunday, February 4, 2007

Deconstructing Thai Propaganda at the Bangkok Post

Nation can lose, but not me

A writer for a popular Thai daily believes that former prime minister Thaksin's hiring of a foreign lobbying firm to polish his image is tantamount to treason


Treason? Now that is taking the rhetoric a little too far. So I guess any Thai who hires a foreign PR firm is considered a traitor.



Former Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra is often said to be better at playing the foreign media than the interim government and the Council for National Security (CNS), noted Nongnuch Singhadecha of Matichon.

Thaksin's latest move was to hire an American lobbyist firm, resulting in the opportunity to air his personal views on CNN and in the The Walt Street Journal.


Several Thai media analysts lauded Thaksin's strategy and wholeheartedly agreed with the former prime minister's belief that those who set out the rules for the game will be the winner.


Is Thaksin smart or are the generals stupid? In terms of playing the international media, Thaksin is smarter. The generals are smart in the sense that they got rid of Thaksin. The generals underestimated Thaksin's ability to fight back, however. Thaksin has tenacity and the drive to win. The generals are resting on their laurels like typical 3rd world dictators. Somebody should tell those boys that we live in a post-modern media age. The generals can act as if it was still the golden age of Thai military dictatorships, but nobody is going to take them seriously, and they will lose the war of attrition in the media.


But very few in the mass media have thought far into the future about the repercussions and adverse effects of Thaksin's game to the country. Nongnuch said Thaksin's hiring a foreign lobbyist to attack Thailand was an act of treason. He resembled the traitor who helped Burma invade Ayutthaya in the past, said the Matichon writer.


Nongnuch said Thaksin was inviting a foreign country to interfere with Thailand's sovereignty.


It looks like Khun Nongnuch went to go see the movie "King Naresuan" one too many times. How is Thaksin inviting a foreign country to interfere with Thailand's sovereignty? US PR firms have the power to shape images. They don't have legal authority to make foreign policy. Nongnuch needs to take a cold shower and get off the "Thailand's sovereignty is threatened" kick.


A lot of large American companies set aside a huge budget for hiring lobbyists to persuade politicians to block laws unfavourable to the companies and pass laws that benefit them.The practice is now commonly accepted, but some American political scientists see the development as destructive to democracy. They regard lobbyists as a fourth branch of power, in addition to the traditional executive, legislative and judiciary branches.


This is not new information. By the way, many organizations besides American companies hire lobbyists. NGOs have lobbyists. Old people have lobbyists. There are lobbies that promote the interests of workers and children. And even foreign governments like Thailand have lobbyists walking the halls of Congress. Some would argue that lobbying is good for democracy, because any group of people can hire an expert to get their issues across to Congressmen. This writer should learn something about the US political system before making judgments about it, especially when that writer lives under a military dictatorship that doesn't guarantee civil liberties.


The unethical practices of lobbyists are widely recognised, and for this reason, when the Democratic Party gained control of the House and the Senate in January, the US Congress passed a historic law restricting their activities. One provision is that a politician can act as a lobbyist only after he has retired from political position for at least two years. Another provision forbids a politician to receive any gifts or accept free travel arranged by lobbyists.


What are the unethical practices of lobbyists? Lobbying is a highly regulated and legal profession in the US. The US, unlike Thailand, actually goes after, punishes and jails politicians and lobbyists who break the law. And what is the point of naming lobbying regulations? It doesn't support this article in any way. Actually, it just reinforces the notion that lobbying is a legal, regulated profession in the US.


The lobbyist firm hired by Thaksin is owned by a former US Republican Party political office holder. Nongnuch believes that the aim of hiring this lobbyist is not only to help pressure the interim government to allow Thaksin to return home, but to help him in other ways by lobbying American politicians - in effect interfering in Thailand's sovereignty.


Both the writer of this article and Nongnuch love to play the nationalist card. Plus, they have no evidence to back up their accusations. What is quite apparent, however, is that Thaksin has hired these PR firms to send out a message. And it is working, because Thaksin is controlling the message.

There is absolutely not one shred of evidence that these US PR firms are intruding upon Thai sovereignty. Neither the White House nor The State Department has made any policy decisions regarding Thailand or its sovereignty because of Thaksin's PR firms. I would actually go so far to say that the US has been extremely patient with this military dictatorship.


The interim government and the CNS must counter by doing some lobbying of their own, said the writer, but not by hiring American lobbyists.


Why not hire a US PR firm to represent Thailand? It is perfectly legal to do so. And it would be much more effective than what the generals are doing now. But as I wrote before, Thais love to do things the Thai way and get Thai results rather than do things the right way and get the right results.


Rather, they should use Thai diplomats stationed in various countries. Nongnuch urged Thai diplomats to seek meetings with American politicians and explain the real situation in this country. One issue that can break Thaksin's back is human rights abuses during his war on drugs.


Another Thaksin weak spot is Burma, whose military junta Thaksin abetted, for example by having Thailand's Ex-Im Bank extend a 4 billion baht soft loan, allegedly to benefit his family's communication business. Mentioning this issue a lot to US politicians, who are vehemently opposed to the Burmese junta, would be enough to dent Thaksin's often-repeated claim to being a champion of democracy.


Even though Nongnuch works at a newspaper, she understands nothing about the US, the media, or politics. The Thai foreign ministry is worthless. They have done absolutely nothing for Thailand's image. They are lousy at public diplomacy. Thailand's image abroad is horrible, but Nongnuch thinks worthless Thai diplomats can fix that. When has a Thai diplomat or the foreign ministry ever done anything for Thailand's general image abroad? The answer is never.


Further, Thaksin is playing a game in the media. The generals have to fight back with a media game of their own. Also, US diplomats and politicians are not going to go on a media campaign in defense of Thailand, especially because it is a military dictatorship. Do Thais live on a different planet or what?


Attacking Thaksin's human right's record is a good idea. But that shouldn't be the role of Thai diplomats. That attack belongs in the realm of a media war, using competent American media experts.


Unfortunately Nongnuch is quite ignorant about how the game is played, because her head is stuck in the clouds with his Thai nationalist propaganda dreams. She must only hear the drums of Bang Rajan beating in her head.


It is obvious that Thaksin does not really intend to quit politics as he has claimed publicly, and he doesn't care if the nation loses as long as he wins, claimed Nongnuch.


Thaksin is showing two faces, the writer continued. For domestic consumption, he proclaims his loyalty to the monarchy and says he will wash his hands of politics to allow the government time to engage in nation building and reconciliation. Yet in his interview with the western press he advocated that Thailand must be a free market economy and attacked the Bank of Thailand's recent measure against hot money speculations against the baht.


So what if Thaksin advocates a free market? How is that treasonous? So what if he attacked the junta's moronic capital control measures that cost the bourse 18% in one day?


Thaksin's emphasis on these two issues was meant to court the western capitalists who dominate their respective countries. By fully declaring that he is 100% pro-free market, Thaksin could be seen as stating his opposition to the use of the sufficiency economy philosophy as a guiding principle in governing the country and economy, which has been adopted by the interim government, said Nongnuch.


I love how Thais love to pull this "Western capitalists are out to get Thailand" bullshit. No country is "100% pro-free market." No country like this exists in the world. Surayud just announced a couple weeks ago that sufficiency theory and capitalism are compatible. What is hysterical Nongnuch getting excited about when Surayud sees no problem?


The sufficiency economy is unique. It has been widely recognised and praised, and the United Nations also adopts the sufficiency economy as a guideline for sustainable economic development without destroying the environment.


Given that his free market policy is against the sufficiency economy, Thaksin should be asked if he is sincere in saying he is loyal to the Thai King, concluded Nongnuch.


More Thai bullshit. The sufficiency economy is not unique. It is common sense.


Where has it been highly praised and recognized?


Name one top economist who praises it?


Again, Surayud and Pridiyathorn have both said free market capitalism and sufficiency theory are compatible. Are they disloyal to the king and his theories?


Quite frankly, I can't believe such a horribly written article made it past the desk editor.

The Junta is Losing its Cool

Govt astonished at 'sufficiency' attacks



Government and military leaders were puzzled yesterday at conflicting signals from ousted prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra, who says he has retired from politics yet continues to give interviews.

"The government remains on course in forging reconciliation and it is up to Thaksin how he shapes his response," said Defence Minister Boonrawd Somtas.


Boonrawd could not understand Thaksin's motives in attacking the sufficiency-economy theory - royal thinking on national development.


"In my opinion, ill-intentioned Thais are a greater threat to their homeland than outside enemies," he said. "Thaksin is free to ramble, but I think the fact the United Nations Development Programme translated and disseminated the sufficiency-economy idea to developing countries is a resounding rebuttal of his comments," he said.


Last month, the UNDP published "Thailand Human Development Report 2007: Sufficiency Economy and Human Development", which hails the sufficiency economy's "middle path" as key to fighting poverty, coping with economic risk and promoting corporate social responsibility.


Boonrawd said the government and the Council for National Security (CNS) would launch a publicity campaign to raise awareness of its achievements and performance rather than react to "political gimmicks" from Thaksin.


Prime Minister Surayud Chulanont reminded Thaksin to maintain loyal to his country before making hasty comments designed to ensure his survival.


"Thaksin should put his Thainess before his self-interest," he said, referring to Thaksin comments implicating the monarchy in the September 19 coup.


Surayud said legal action may have to be considered if Thaksin continued to make "wild allegations" in an irresponsible manner.


CNS deputy chairman Air Chief Marshal Chalit Pukphasuk said the council would not tolerate attempts to tarnish the country's most revered institution.


CNS assistant secretary-general Anupong Paochinda said Thaksin should realise his comments stirred the political pot and drove a wedge between people.


"Innuendoes are not constructive, particularly while the CNS is trying to restore normalcy and enable the nation to move forward," he said, in reference to Thaksin's allegation that corruption is on the rise following the coup.


A Foreign Ministry spokesman said the ministry had gathered all interviews given by Thaksin to foreign media and submitted them to the premier, waiting to see if he will decide on any particular policy about the case.


Democrat Party deputy leader Alongkorn Pollabutr said his party would tomorrow release a report of 34 acts of graft allegedly involving the ousted government.


Meanwhile yesterday, Thaksin's lawyer Nopadol Pattama revealed that Thaksin had scheduled more interviews with various foreign media, including television and newspapers. He claimed Thaksin had a right to speak, and that what he spoke about was all positive for Thailand.


"To ask Thaksin to speak less to foreign media would need further consultation with him," Nopadol said.


Vinij Krathong, a member of Law Society of Thailand's Committee on Lawyers' Code of Conduct, revealed the society was considering reviewing the activities of Nopadol in the Thaksin case and whether they violate the code of conduct for lawyers.


"It is understandable that he speaks for his client, but is he speaking too much and beyond the role of a lawyer?" he said.


Winij spoke at a meeting on lawyers' ethics in Phitsanulok, joined by the United States' American Bar Association-Asia Law Initiative.



The Junta is really losing it if all they have after four months is a baseless accusation that Thaksin is attacking sufficiency theory and the monarchy. They have had plenty of time to go after other crimes.

Do they understand how stupid they sound?

And The Nation should be ashamed of itself for promoting this propaganda, considering that it has been on the other end of politically inspired lese majestie charges.


Saturday, February 3, 2007

The Economist's slight Jab against Thailand

Royal gala performances

Re: King Naresuan


The army and the monarchy are box-office moneyspinners



IF THE secret of success in the cinema is to anticipate the popular mood, Thailand's film industry should be feeling pretty chuffed. It seems to have foreseen, even before last September's royally endorsed military coup, that the army and the monarchy were about to move into the centre of the action.



Deconstructing Commisioner Mehdi's Defense of "Sufficiency Theory"

The philosophy behind the sufficiency economy

The economic crisis of 1997 affected everyone in Thailand, even His Majesty the King. Seeing many of his subjects suffering, he advised the Thai people to change their economic philosophy in order to cope with present economic adversity and withstand future economic insecurity.

OK, let us look at the context of 1997 crisis:

During the 1990's Thailand was booming. Thais were borrowing capital from abroad to finance stock and real estate speculation. When imbalances in the Thai economy came about, many foreign lenders called in their loans. Many private financing companies couldn't afford to pay back these loans and what collateral existed was mortgaged to the hilt, so the Thai government had to cover these losses. This, plus a growing a trade deficit threw the Thai government into bankruptcy in the sense that it no longer had any foreign reserves. So the Thai government had to borrow from abroad to cover its trade deficits. But in order to get this money, the IMF and member lenders told the Thai government it had to reform its economy. Thailand took the terms of loans and reformed their economy. Thailand went through a lot of pain for a year and a half, but bounced back fairly quickly.

The problem was never globalization or foreign trade. The problem was Thai greed. But Thais never take responsibility for their actions, so it is easier to blame somebody else or some other entity for their problems.

So during the post-crisis period, many Thai intellectuals chose to go after the IMF, the US, George Soros, the Jews, globalization, Washington Consensus policies, anything else besides the Thais and the institutional structures of the Thai state and economy that were responsible for the problems in the first place.


His Majesty's words have become known as the philosophy behind the sufficiency economy and have been used as the guiding principles in the drafting of the current Ninth National Economic and Social Development Plan.


What does this mean? Thais should never submit anything in the English language without a good copy editor. What are His Majesty's words exactly? How can you discuss words without the text? This kind of sloppy writing makes me want to pull my hair out.


The philosophy is summed up in the following paragraph: sufficiency economy is a philosophy that guides the livelihood and behaviour of people at all levels, from the family to the community to the country, on matters concerning national development and administration. It calls for a "middle way" to be observed, especially in pursuing economic development in keeping with the world of globalisation. Sufficiency means moderation and reasonableness, including the need to build a reasonable immune system against shocks from the outside or from the inside. Intelligence, attentiveness, and extreme care should be used to ensure that all plans and every step of their implementation are based on knowledge. At the same time we must build up the spiritual foundation of all people in the nation, especially state officials, scholars, and business people at all levels, so they are conscious of moral integrity and honesty and they strive for the appropriate wisdom to live life with forbearance, diligence, self-awareness, intelligence, and attentiveness. In this way we can hope to maintain balance and be ready to cope with rapid physical, social, environmental, and cultural changes from the outside world.


Basically the king is telling people the same thing our teachers and parents have told us for generations: "Don't buy what you can't afford." "Don't borrow what you can't pay back." "Work hard and play by the rules." " There is no such thing as a free lunch." "Don't lie, cheat and steal." "Save your money for a rainy day." "Spend a little, save a little."

Most Thai intellectuals are idiots. Instead of relying on pedantic rhetoric, they should speak clearly and concisely. They should stop distorting the meaning of the English language with a lot of inane gibberish. Nobody is impressed with a large vocabulary if that vocabulary does nothing but cover up a sloppy analysis.

The King is advocating common sense. There is no theory.


This philosophical statement has lent itself to interpretation by diverse groups of people. First, we can dismiss outright the extreme interpretation that sufficiency economy means complete self-reliance, or autarky. In an autarkic system, a country or unit thereof relies upon itself and its people to produce all of its needs with no dependence on others. It may do this voluntarily (cutting off contact with the outside world) or by necessity (because it is incapable of generating those contacts). But His Majesty the King explicitly rejected this interpretation: "This self-sufficiency does not mean that every family must grow food for themselves, to make clothes for themselves; that is too much. But in a village or sub-district there should be a reasonable amount of sufficiency. If they grow or produce something more than they need they can sell them. But they do not need to sell them very far; they can sell them in nearby places without having to pay high transport costs."



There is no philosophical statement. King Bumibol isn't Socrates. Thailand can't be autarkic, because Thailand doesn't produce anything of value on its own. Every aspect of Thailand's modernization it owes to foreigners, foreign trade and globalization. Most Thai farmers, however, can live an autarkic existence. In other words, it is possible that Thai peasants and their communities can take care of their basic needs first before selling what they have for a profit. What troubles the elites is that Thai peasants want a taste of good life, the life that they see on TV, like when royalty, politicians and movie stars in Bangkok are living in fancy mansions, driving Mercedes, and talking on expensive mobile phones. Why is it always the peasant who is asked to sacrifice, but those who are exploiting and stealing from the masses never sacrifice shit? When was the last time you saw a Thai big shot take public transportation or use a public telephone?

Also, funny how nobody talks about the Chinese middle man/distribution network that has been screwing the farmers for hundreds of years. Nobody talks about the Thai bureaucrats who have been cheating the farmers out of the value of their work and products by subsidizing rice to Bangkokians and for external export. Nobody should lecture the peasants without addressing exploitation, which the monarchy has a long history of sustaining.

The problems that exist in Thailand have nothing to do with sufficiency. The problems are institutional.


Some people have attempted to link this economic philosophy with the so-called "Gandhian Economy". Along the lines proposed by Mahatma Gandhi, this is an economy based on family-level or village-level small-scale enterprises and traditional methods. It may have been appropriate to India in the mid-twentieth century, when the people were poor and technology was limited. But in the present, it may be too restrictive to expect families to do everything by themselves using simple tools and machinery, such as traditional spinning wheels to make cloth. Perhaps the basic idea of Gandhian simplicity - a life less encumbered by modern needs and modern technology - could make people happier. But in the very open world of today, self-sufficiency a la Gandhi is too extreme.


Who is linking King Bumibol's Sufficiency rhetoric with Ghandi? So what is exactly the distinction? What is too extreme? What is the paradigm of extremeness?


We also hear people relating the sufficiency economy to the knowledge and applicability of Buddhism. In Buddhism, life, especially spiritual life, is enhanced by cutting out excessive wants and greed. True happiness may be attained when a person is fully satisfied with what he or she has and is at peace with the self. To strive to consume more leads to unhappiness if (or when) consumption is not satisfied or falls short of expectations. A sufficiency economy in this context would be an economy fundamentally conditioned by basic need, not greed, and restrained by a conscious effort to cut consumption. This is probably acceptable insofar as it does not reject gains in welfare and well-being due to greater consumption.


What is this mealy-mouthed bullshit? Who determines "True Happiness?" Who determines what is enough consumption? How is this any different from the Ghandi model? Why does this paragraph contradict itself? I love this sentence: "True happiness may be attained when a person is fully satisfied with what he or she has..." This is a line the elite has used to keep Thais enslaved for centuries while the elite gobbles up the resources of the state, sells it abroad for a profit, then uses the money to buy luxury goods and a hi-so lifestyle.


His Majesty has talked about the sufficiency idea since 1974. In his customary birthday speech of that year, he wished everyone in Thailand "sufficient to live and to eat" (por yoo por kin). This was indeed a precursor to the sufficiency economy. His Majesty also said: "The development of a country must be by steps. It must start with basic sufficiency in food and adequate living, using techniques and instruments that are economical but technically sound. When this foundation is secured, then higher economic status and progress can be established." (See Apichai Puntasen, "The King's Sufficiency Economy and Its Interpretation by Economists".)


How does the king's model differ from the Ghandi and Buddhist models when the rhetoric is the same?


This is very clear: it shows that His Majesty did not deny economic progress and globalisation, as some people have interpreted. Indeed the word globalisation is used in the statement on sufficiency economy that His Majesty has endorsed. The notion that sufficiency economy is anti-globalisation should be put to rest forever.


Nothing is clear. Nobody knows what the hell they are talking about, and try to pretend that they do with a lot of bullshit. Nothing this guy has written supports or rejects the king's views on globalization, which are totally unknown.


Still, there are attempts by various segments of the Thai population to dissociate this new economy from the realm of mainstream economics that stresses economic rationality and efficiency in resource allocation. It is obvious that His Majesty's sufficiency economy is not the type found in a mainstream economics textbook, but it would be inaccurate to interpret it as the antithesis of mainstream economics in every respect. On the contrary, I think we can understand sufficiency economy within the framework of economic rationality and efficiency in choices. The difference is not in type, but in degree or magnitude of economic behaviour. His Majesty used the phrase "middle path" or "middle way" to describe the pattern of life every Thai should lead - a life dictated by moderation, reasonableness and the ability to withstand shock. Can we find something in mainstream economics that captures the spirit of this philosophy?


More Thai bullshit. Another paragraph that says nothing. Capitalism/globalization is based on making a profit, a return on investment, which is antithetical to a feudal socialist or sufficiency model. There is no such thing as sufficiency globalization. Capital searches for profits abroad, not sufficiency.


I propose to use my own understanding of economic optimisation. It is possible to see the sufficiency economy as consisting of two frameworks. One is the inevitability of facing the globalised world in which economic efficiency and competition are the rules of the game; the other is the need for economic security and the capacity to protect oneself from external shock and instability. Thinking within the first framework - the basic tenet of mainstream economics - we must realise the opportunity costs involved in every decision we make. We gain from specialisation and division of labour because the opportunity costs of doing everything by ourselves is much higher. But it would be foolish to pursue all-out specialisation without basic security, especially in food, shelter and clothing. This is where the framework of the new sufficiency economy comes in. This concerns the basic capacity of the people of a country to look after themselves. The optimisation principle applies when we seek to answer the question: how much of our time and energy should be devoted to the first and second frameworks, respectively? In other words, how much resources should be allocated to producing for trade based on the comparative advantage principle, and how much for basic security? The best mix between the two allocations would represent the optimal state of affairs, both in mainstream and sufficiency economics.


This is my interpretation, which is consistent with Thai policy: The Thai economy is for Thais only. We should protect our food, our land, and our industries first. Take things from the foreigners that help us, but screw them wherever you can in any way you can without it costing us any money or making any sacrifices. Keep the farmers poor and stupid, so that they don't use their mental and physical resources to sell their labor power in the market place, and keep them so stupid that they don't challenge the aristocratic and capitalist elites that don't practice what they preach. In other words, this guy wants to keep the status quo.



Medhi Krongkaew is a commissioner of the National Counter Corruption Commission.


Who is this guy? What kind of home does he live in? What kind of car does he drive? Where does he send his kids to school? What kinds of toys and gadgets does he have? How many wives does he support?

He is on the NCCC, yet what has he done to rein in Thai greed and corruption? What is his record in using the law in putting an end to the corrupt excesses of Thai politicians and bureaucrats?


Friday, February 2, 2007

Newsweek's Take on "Sufficiency Economics"

Buddhist Economics

Thailand is now charting a 'middle path' set out by its beloved king. But will new measures bolster the shaky junta, or simply kill the economy?


Jan. 22, 2007 issue - Thailand's finance minister, Pridiyathorn Devakula, said the new rules were meant merely to "close loopholes." But that's not how foreign business leaders saw it last week, when he briefed them in Bangkok on plans to revise the country's investment restrictions. They viewed the move as starkly protectionist, according to one participant. In the tense discussion that followed, the visitors peppered the minister with pointed questions, warning that the measures could be challenged at the World Trade Organization. "There's a fundamental philosophical gap," said the source. "It became obvious we were getting nowhere."





Thursday, February 1, 2007

More Sufficiency Bullshit from The Nation

Explaining sufficiency economy to foreigners is important, but it is vital for govt to instill its values here



For the benefit of people who still need to be convinced that a sufficiency economy is preferable to Thaksinomics as Thailand's economic management model, Deputy Prime Minister MR Pridiyathorn Devakula offered easy-to-follow arguments backed by compelling reasons in a letter published in yesterday's edition of The Wall Street Journal. In the letter, he addressed the widely misunderstood concept of the sufficiency-economy model. He said a sufficiency economy was neither an economic paradigm nor an economic theory, but rather a philosophy that could be applied to all aspects of life, including economic affairs.


"A sufficiency economy does not deny the principles of globalisation and the market economy, which have been the pillars of our economic management and will continue as such. Two key principles of the sufficiency-economy philosophy are 'moderation' and 'self-immunity'," he wrote.


One possible reason why the concept has been misinterpreted so often is because it sounds too much like Mahatma Gandhi's "village-based self-sufficiency", which was totally different. In his non-violent struggle for independence from then-imperial British rulers, Gandhi urged the development of village-based self-sufficiency in India. To illustrate his point, he referred to the spinning wheel as a symbol for civil disobedience and a practical method of non-cooperation against the British textile monopoly. But then, only the ignorant could have confused the two concepts, which leaves us with the other reason why Thailand's sufficiency-economy model has been so consistently misconstrued even by intelligent people. The concept has been deliberately mislabelled and misrepresented, because many foreigners are reluctant to let go of Thaksinomics, which was, and continues to be, seen as more business-friendly than the sufficiency-economy model.


Perhaps that is because the sufficiency-economy model advocates moderation and immunity. As Pridiyathorn put it, moderation that would "remind us not to grow or expand beyond our capacity, which results in economic excess or bubbles". He said building immunity would remind us to introduce proper risk-management systems and good governance, to safeguard our economic stability and improve our resiliency against the shocks and changes that come with globalisation.


Thaksinomics is a catch-phrase that covers deposed PM Thaksin Shinawatra's economic-management style aimed primarily at boosting economic growth at all costs. Thaksinomics is characterised by an unprincipled, often whimsical, economic-management style that is not hedged against the negative impact of globalisation and the corroding effects of political corruption. Thaksinomics could have had a devastating effect on the Thai economy if Thaksin had not been stopped when he was removed from power on September 19. Policies implemented under Thaksinomics coupled with populist policies that pandered to the unprincipled wants of people have accumulated whopping Bt150 billion worth of debts, both on and off the budget.


These debts accumulated mostly because Thaksin rushed through populist policies to score quick political points without concerning himself with the crucial question of how to fund them, as a responsible leader should. The sufficiency-economy model is far from perfect and still has room for improvement and refinement but nevertheless diametrically opposed to everything that is bad about Thaksinomics. Our question to critics who jump to conclusions by dismissing it out of hand as "inward-looking" or "anti-foreigner", among other negative labels is: what is there not to like about it?


It is important for the Surayud government to continue to try to explain it to foreign governments and international investors. But of greater importance is determining how to educate our citizens, particularly the rural masses still enamoured with Thaksin's populist policies, about the financial ruin that Thailand may have narrowly averted when corruption-prone Thaksin was removed from power in disgrace.


People must shown Thaksin's irresponsible populism for what it was. They must understand that his game was based on the false premise that the entitlements he showered on people, particularly rural folk, were something they could enjoy without worrying about how the government would pay for it. The truth of the matter is there is no such thing as a free lunch. Taxpayers will have to start paying for Thaksin's populist excess and the mountain of debt he incurred.